F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Post by **Londoner** » 24 Mar 2013, 16:58

No sign of this thread, oddly.

Vettel - 8 - I'll be fair, he did put in a cracking drive to win. Doesn't get full points though because of his whinging.
Webber - 9 - He deserved to win.

Alonso - 1 - What the bloody hell was that?! Seriously boneheaded decision to press on with a damaged wing, with predictable results.
Massa - 7 - Yeah, he was alright.

Button - 9 - Barnstorming drive that sadly counted for nothing. Go home McLaren.
Perez - 6 - Fair enough, he scored points

Raikkonen - 5 - Strangely off-kilter today.
Grosjean - 8 - One of very few drivers to keep their nose clean today.

Hamilton - 7 - Alright I suppose.
Rosberg - 5 - Stop whinging and just pass him!

Hulkenberg - 8 - Proving himself again
Guttierez - 5 - Perez Mk 2 he isn't.

Di Resta - 6 - Screwed over by his team.
Sutil - 6 - Screwed over by his team.

Maldonado - 1 - For bathplug sake Pastor...
Bottas - 6 - Much better.

Ricciardo - 4 - Did sod-all
Vergne - 4 - Utter plonker.

Pic - 5 - Meh
Van Der Garde - 6 - I'll give him his due, he wasn't awful out there, unlike most of the rest of the field.

Bianchi - 9 - Oh yeah!
Chilton - 4 - Not brilliant today.

Shizuka · Post by **Shizuka** » 24 Mar 2013, 17:05

Vettel - 8
Webber - 9

Alonso - 1
Massa - 6

Button - 9
Perez - 5

Raikkonen - 4
Grosjean - 7

Hamilton - 6
Rosberg - 6

Hulkenberg - 8
Guttierez - 4

Di Resta - 5
Sutil - 5

Maldonado - 1
Bottas - 5

Ricciardo - 5
Vergne - 6

Pic - 4
Van Der Garde - 5

Bianchi - 7
Chilton - 2

Teams:
Red Bull - 8
Ferrari - 4
McLaren - 3
Lotus - 6
Mercedes - 7
Sauber - 6
Force India - 2
Williams - 3
Toro Rosso - 3
Caterham - 4
Marussia - 6

James1978 · Post by **James1978** » 24 Mar 2013, 17:21

Vettel 5 - yes I agree about his driving but was it a fair fight if Webber originally thought they were holding station? Also loses points for his fake apology.
Webber 9 - hope this spurs him on to some more Silverstone-esque performances.
Red Bull 5 - stop whinging about the tyres

Alonso 2 - Was it Maldonado in that car? Terrible error on a day when he could have really beenefitted from the Red Bull controversy too
Massa 6 - Solid but he was being groomed as a potential winner pre-race
Ferrari 4 - oh dear

Button 9 - he's really knuckling down to take the team forward
Perez 6 - doesn't seem to have an edge in wheel-to-wheel combat
McLaren 6 - they're getting somehwere but need to iron out the pitstop problems

Raikkonen 5 - needs less days like days to be a championship contender
Grosjean 8 - quietly impressive which is just what he needs at the moment
Lotus 6 - where did the Austrlia performance go?

Rosberg 9 - anyone who thought Hamilton would steamroller him (including me) is really wrong!
Hamilton 8 - good but loses a mark for the pitstop error (to be fair it wasn't as bad as Button's similar mistake because Button's never drove for Red Bull and their crew looks nothing like McLaren's!!). He couldn't help being underfuelled though.
Mercedes 9 - good to see them worrying Red Bull. Give the drivers more fuel to push though!!

Hulkenberg 8 - what we expected of him in Oz
Gutierrez 5 - still looks a bit out of his depth
Sauber 7 - shame they don't yet have two drivers operating on a similar level.

Sutil 6 - was actually getting outpaced by his teammate
Di Resta 8 - his pace was very good, messed up in qualifying but was making amends in the race before the team's problems intervened
Force India 2 - sort it out guys!!

Maldonado 2 - what on earth are you doing?
Bottas 7 - he's doing Ok isn't he?
Williams 4 - shame about needing that Venezualan clot to pay for his drive....

Vergne 7 - first time he's scored points for a position other than 8th
Riccciardo 5 - ruining his diffuser on your out lap is all I can remember him doing!
Toro Rosso 4

Pic 5
Van Der Garde 4
Caterham 3

Bianchi 9
Chilton 5
Marussia 8

GwilymJJames · Post by **GwilymJJames** » 24 Mar 2013, 17:27

Vettel - 9 - Good driving
Webber - 7 - Stop whinging. Try to take the position back.

Alonso - 2 - WTF
Massa - 8 -

Button - 8
Perez - 6

Raikkonen - 6
Grosjean - 7

Hamilton - 7
Rosberg - 7 - Stop whinging. Try to take the position.

Hulkenberg - 6
Guttierez - 5

Di Resta - 6
Sutil - 6

Maldonado - 3
Bottas - 6

Ricciardo - 5
Vergne - 7

Pic - 6
Van Der Garde - 5

Bianchi - 7
Chilton - 5

Divina_Galica · Post by **Divina_Galica** » 24 Mar 2013, 17:27

Vettel - 8 - Great pole lap. Manged tyres. Saw off Webber

Webber - 7 - Not convinced he deserved to win. Despite your team-mate disobeying team orders you don't try and shove them into the pit wall
Red Bull - 8 A 1-2 finish not to be sneezed at. China etc will be interesting

Alonso - 2 - Just ran into back of Vettel. Dumb, just dumb.
Massa - 6 - Went backwards.
Ferrari - 5 Understood why they didn't pull Alonso in but hilarious consequences

Button - 10 - Brilliant drive that sadly counted for nothing.
Perez - 6 - Fair enough, he scored points, agreed
McLaren - 7 Getting car working, but time for a reboot on wheels

Raikkonen - 6 - Struggled, maybe we will find there were car problems - he did go grasstracking a couple of times
Grosjean - 8 - One of very few drivers to keep their nose clean today, agreed
Lotus - 7 Car not happy in these conditions

Hamilton - 7 - At least had the grace to apologise on the podium
Rosberg - 5 - Outpaced hamilton for a lot of the time.
Mercedes - great points haul - Brawn masterly in handling of Rosberg

Hulkenberg - 7 - Proving himself again - but not great running into Raikkonen
Guttierez - 5 - Perez Mk 2 he isn't. Never thought he was....
Sauber - 6 Not as good as last year are they?

Di Resta - 9 - Screwed over by his team in Q2, first pitstop behind Sutil, got back into contention, then totally bathplugged over....
Sutil - 6 - Screwed over by his team, but didn't have anything like di Restas pace in the race
FI - 0 Sort it out!

Maldonado - 4 - Always entertaining...
Bottas - 5 - Always invisible (so far...)
Williams - 4 So much more expected this year

Ricciardo - 4 - Dropped it before the race even started
Vergne - 4 - Surely he won't keep that point. "Go, go go ........ooops, stop, stop, stop...."
STR - 4 Hmmm, aiming for 6th in WCC ??

Pic - 5 - Air Asia guests got to see their cars for almost all the laps
Van Der Garde - 6 - Not actually as bad a feared.
Caterham - 3 Interesting shade of green

Bianchi - 7 - Didn't really beat anyone did he
Chilton - 5 - Didn't even get much TV time....
Marussia - 7 Much mproved over 2012

DG

Divina_Galica · Post by **Divina_Galica** » 24 Mar 2013, 17:31

James1978 wrote:Rosberg 9 - anyone who thought Hamilton would steamroller him (including me) is really wrong!
Hamilton 8 - good but loses a mark for the pitstop error (to be fair it wasn't as bad as Button's similar mistake because Button's never drove for Red Bull and their crew looks nothing like McLaren's!!). He couldn't help being underfuelled though.
Mercedes 9 - good to see them worrying Red Bull. Give the drivers more fuel to push though!!

Sutil 6 - was actually getting outpaced by his teammate
Di Resta 8 - his pace was very good, messed up in qualifying but was making amends in the race before the team's problems intervened
Force India 2 - sort it out guys!!

I can't think that Mercedes put less fuel into Lewis' car than Nico's so Rosberg was doing a much better job given fuel available to them...

Di Resta's Q2 mess up was team calling him in just before the rain fell and then he had no chance of getting into Q3 once parts of track were wet

DG

DOSBoot · Post by **DOSBoot** » 24 Mar 2013, 18:11

Vettel - 8: Great recovery to win, but his hanlding of team orders cost him.
Webber - 9: Should have won this race. I hope we see more of these drives from him.

Alonso - 1: No wonder he's losing championships! He can't stop making these stupid mistakes!
Massa - 7: Qualified well, but dropped back.

Button - 9: Amazing run, but his team messed it up for him.
Perez - 7: Scored points, but can do better.

Raikkonen - 6: Off the pace, and hot-headed today.
Grosjean - 8: Kept out out of trouble again.

Hamilton - 8: Made a couple mistakes, but was good overall.
Rosberg - 8: Very quick, and handled the his short end of the stick better than Vettel ever did.

Hulkenberg - 8: Points for Sauber.
Guttierez - 6: A bit of a blocker.

Di Resta - 6: Screwed by the team.
Sutil - 6: Screwed by the team.

Maldonado - 2: His seat for next year might be in trouble.
Bottas - 7: Almost scored a point.

Ricciardo - 4: Terrible.
Vergne - 6: Lucky point.

Pic - 5: Still slow, but faster than last week.
Van Der Garde - 5: Still slow, but faster than last week.

Bianchi - 8: To boldly go where no Marussia has gone before.
Chilton - 3: Spanked by both Caterhams.

Ed24 · Post by **Ed24** » 24 Mar 2013, 18:19

Vettel - 9
Webber - 9

Alonso - 3
Massa - 7

Button - 9
Perez -5

Raikkonen - 5
Grosjean - 8

Hamilton - 8
Rosberg - 8

Hulkenberg - 8
Guttierez - 5

Di Resta - 6
Sutil - 6

Maldonado - 2
Bottas - 7

Ricciardo - 4
Vergne - 6

Pic - 5
Van Der Garde - 5

Bianchi - 8
Chilton - 4

Shadaza · Post by **Shadaza** » 24 Mar 2013, 18:48

Vettel - 8 = A good drive but it should have been Webbers race.
Webber - 7 = Beat Vettel on strategy, lost it because Vettel is a little backstabbing shite who can't be trusted. Edit. Minus 2 for the pitlane swerves

Alonso - 1 = I don't give many ones, but that was awful and beyond stupid. If he had hit someone after his wing fell that would have deserved a penalty for Shanghai!
Massa - 7 = Anonymous, and considering expectation that was a bad thing. Got 5th by default. Though only so far behind because of poor inter pace

Button - 10 = My driver of the race, flawless performance and managing to save tires to be within a sniff of the leaders in that POS, McLaren screwed him over.
Perez - 5 = Mediocre, again

Raikkonen - 4 = all Over the place in the car with the upgrades!
Grosjean - 8 = Put his head down and drove solidly to take a well deserved 6th.

Hamilton - 8 = Couldn't challenge Red Bull during the final stint but did well to mix with them at all, team told him to slow at the end.
Rosberg - 8 = Much stronger pace then was allowed to show but really no better or worse then Hamilton, they seem equally matched so far this year.

Hulkenberg - 8 = Looked fantastic in the wet and managed to run well in the top 10 all race, minus a point for losing out to Raikkonen
Guttierez - 3 = I miss Kobayashi. Despite not being involved in any drama manages to finish behind a crappy Williams and Vergne who was delayed in the pits for nearly a minute!

Di Resta - 6 = was massively fast down the straights but the team robbed him of a good result, had the measure over Sutil.
Sutil - 5 = Slower then Di Resta but doing ok, team screwed him over.

Maldonado - 3 = Slow, ragged, all over the place. Also had time to trash a front wing. Where has his mojo gone? Though his retirement was down to KERS.
Bottas - 7 = There is hope for Bottas yet, that was a nice drive.

Ricciardo - 5 = Seemed ok in the wet but faded in the dry, not really sure what happened so head scratching on that
Vergne - 7 = Pitlane crash wasn't his fault, recovered well to score a point.

Pic - 7 = Blameless for the Vergne crash in the pits, had a real chance of catching Bianchi otherwise.
Van Der Garde - 7 = Had a great start and only just lost out to Pic, maybe not as useless as I thought.

Bianchi - 7 = Didn't dominate the minor teams as much as the last race, but still a great result.
Chilton - 3 = Pace is woeful but at least he is a safe pair of hands

AndreaModa · Post by **AndreaModa** » 24 Mar 2013, 19:09

Vettel -- 8
Webber -- 8

Alonso -- 2
Massa -- 6

Button -- 7
Perez --6

Raikkonen -- 5
Grosjean -- 6

Hamilton -- 6
Rosberg -- 6

Hulkenberg -- 6
Guttierez -- 5

Di Resta -- 5
Sutil -- 5

Maldonado -- 3
Bottas -- 5

Ricciardo -- 4
Vergne -- 5

Pic -- 4
Van Der Garde -- 5

Bianchi -- 6
Chilton -- 4

Meatwad · Post by **Meatwad** » 24 Mar 2013, 20:20

Vettel 10
Webber 10
(Red Bull Racing 10)

Alonso 2
Massa 8
(Ferrari 5)

Button 10 :cry:

Pérez 8
(McLaren 4)

Räikkönen 7
Grosjean 9
(Lotus 7)

Rosberg 10
Hamilton 10
(Mercedes 10)

Hülkenberg 9
Gutiérrez 7
(Sauber 8)

Di Resta 7
Sutil 7
(Force India 1 :roll:

)

Maldonado 3
Bottas 8
(Williams 6)

Vergne 8
Ricciardo 7
(STR 7)

Pic 8
Van der Garde 7
(Caterham 6)

Bianchi 9
Chilton 6
(Marussia 8)

DidNotQualify · Post by **DidNotQualify** » 24 Mar 2013, 20:51

Vettel 9 - Leaving aside the morals of the pass on Webber, it was a great move to watch. The early change to slicks was a bit iffy though.
Webber 8 - The start was great, his shove on Vettel less pretty. But if he can keep this sort of driving up he'll give Seb a hard time.

Alonso 2 - Bonus point for keeping Webber behind him for a whole lap without a front wing. The only good thing for him today...
Massa 5 - The much-vaunted Ferrari race pace disappeared. Lucky to finish 5th.

Button 9 - If only he'd stayed in the race the whole Mercedes business would have been a lot more interesting.
Perez 5 - Ends his pointless streak. Also starting to emulate Raikkonen in collecting those fastest laps.

Raikkonen 4 - Limply gives up all the momentum from Melbourne with a scrappy race.
Grosjean 7 - Kept it on the island well.

Rosberg 8 - A little quicker than Hamilton over a race distance, but Lewis kept getting the undercut. I do think he could have finished 3rd even without the team orders debacle had he passed Hamilton in the 2nd DRS zone when he got close.
Hamilton 7 - Took the race to the Red Bulls well, but probably peaked too early. Loses a point for pitlane blunder.

Hulkenberg 7 - Top midfield runner in this race. That's how to open your 2013 account.
Gutierrez 4 - Even more anonymous than in Australia.

Di Resta 6 - Was ahead of his teammate before the pit stop farce.
Sutil 5 - Squandered qualifying advantage.

Maldonado 2 - Dismal.
Bottas 6 - Quietly effective and nearly sneaked into the points.

Vergne 6 - Did a solid job to score his first point of the season.
Ricciardo 5 - I do think JEV has had the upper hand so far.

Pic 5 - The only thing I saw of him was his collision with Vergne in the pits.
Van Der Garde 5 - Beat a Marussia home.

Bianchi 7 - Only 1 lap down is pretty good in a race with no safety car. Extra point for Q1 heroics.
Chilton 3 - Steady, outclassed by Bianchi.

RonDenisDeletraz · Post by **RonDenisDeletraz** » 24 Mar 2013, 22:42

Vettel 7
Webber 8

Alonso 3
Massa 6

Button 7
Perez 5

Raikkonen 5
Grosjean 5

Rosberg 8
Hamilton 6

Hulkenberg 7
Gutirriez 4

Di Resta 5
Sutil 6

Maldolan 1
Bottas 4

Ricciardo 4
Vernge 5

Pic 5
Van Derp Garde 4

Bianchi 8
Chilton 4

QuickYoda41 · Post by **QuickYoda41** » 24 Mar 2013, 23:05

Vettel - 8
Webber - 10

Alonso - 1
Massa - 6

Button - 8
Perez - 6

Raikkonen - 5
Grosjean - 7

Hamilton - 7
Rosberg - 8

Hulkenberg - 7
Guttierez - 5

Di Resta - 6
Sutil - 6

Maldonado - 2
Bottas - 6

Ricciardo - 6
Vergne - 6

Pic - 5
Van Der Garde - 6

Bianchi - 7
Chilton - 4

Klon · Post by **Klon** » 24 Mar 2013, 23:33

Vettel - 10 - A good drive and in the end, it's 25 points which you have or don't.
Webber - 9 - That'll teach him to never trust a Kraut again.

Alonso - 1 - It's just awful, mate
Massa - 8 - Probably as good as the car allowed him to be

Button - 9 - Well, I had him at IIDOTR prediction and he performed beyond exceptions
Perez - 6 - A reasonable job, nothing more, nothing less

Raikkonen - 4 - He just didn't bring it, well, can only be good for my avatar.
Grosjean - 8 - See Massa.

Hamilton - 9 - Actually able to challenge the Red Bull, even though he screwed up fuel planning whilst doing so
Rosberg - 9 - Well, he was behind Hamilton when told to stay there, but other than that a great drive.

Hulkenberg - 9 - Pushed the possibilities and Räikkönen nearly off the track
Guttierez - 4 - A weak performance, he is still new

DOSBoot wrote:Di Resta - 6 - Screwed over by his team.
Sutil - 6 - Screwed over by his team.

Maldonado - 4 - Tried too hard but going from a top tier Williams to a shite tier one does that to you
Bottas - 7 - Tried to make the best out of his situation and succeeded.

Ricciardo - 5 - ... part I
Vergne - 7 - ... part II - he did get a point out of it, though.

Pic - 5 - Well, after the crashtastic pitstop which was not his fault he didn't go anywhere
Van Der Garde - 6 - Well, why not acknowledge his improvement.

Bianchi - 9 - He remains the measuring stick for the lowest third of the grid.
Chilton - 4 - No craze today, my love's gone away.[/quote]

Onxy Wrecked · Post by **Onxy Wrecked** » 25 Mar 2013, 00:14

Vettel: 10
Webber: 9, didn't choke like in the land of OZ

Alonso: 1, and probably doesn't even deserve that much
Massa: 8

Button: 9, too bad the wheel didn't allow more.
Perez: 7, decent day

Raikkonen: 5, not the miracle run of last week.
Grosjean: 8, better than Raikkonen

Hamilton: 9
Rosberg: 10, defied my expectations

Hulkenberg: 8
Gutierrez: 5, the most invisible man in F1

Di Resta and Sutil: NA as the mechanics failed with wheels

Maldonado: 5, not the most terrible we've seen from him.
Bottas: 8, he finished on the lead lap and Maldonado didn't finish at all.

Ricciardo: Driver: 6, Exhaust System: 0 He's cursed or something.
Vergne: 6, not a bad drive after starting 17th.

Pic: 5
Van Der Garde: 8, for not crashing and successfully passing Chilton

Bianchi: 10, he's not going to be at Marussia if he keeps on taking Marussia cars to the level of Saubers who qualified 5 positions in front of him.
Chilton: 3, got passed by Van Der Garde and barely in front of Jenson Button who had a wheel failure.

Dj_bereta · Post by **Dj_bereta** » 25 Mar 2013, 00:16

Vettel - 8: He did well, despite the team orders-gate.
Webber - 9: He did a fantastic job but the team helped him lose the victory.

Alonso - 1: WTF!? Big mistake of Nando and Ferrari in not pit with a damaged front wing.
Massa - 7: Good race, but Massa struggled in the rain.

Button - 8: Very good race.
Perez - 6: Ok, but spend most of time fighting with the Hulk, who has an inferior car.

Raikkonen - 5: Good recovery from mistake, but, mistakes are mistakes.
Grosjean - 8: A solid race, way better than kimi.

Hamilton - 8: Very good race
Rosberg - 8: Very good race too.

Hulkenberg - 9: Fought against Lotuses, Mclarens and Massa with an inferior car.
Guttierez - 3: Did mistakes and spend most of time around Toro Rosso and Williams cars.

Di Resta - 7: Retirement isn't your fault.
Sutil - 7:Retirement isn't your fault too

Maldonado - 2: Overdriving again, crashed again and retired again.
Bottas - 7: Good race with a lackluster car.

Ricciardo - 6: Fine race.
Vergne - 7: Scores a point. Good job

Pic - 5 Ok
Van Der Garde - 5 Ok

Bianchi - 8: Another very good race. He will score points in chaotic races.
Chilton - 3: Completely owned by Bianchi.

the Masked Lapwing · Post by **the Masked Lapwing** » 25 Mar 2013, 02:30

Vettel - 4
Webber - 9

Alonso - 1
Massa - 6

Button - 7
Perez - 6

Raikkonen - 5
Grosjean - 6

Rosberg - 8
Hamilton - 7

Hulkenberg - 7
Gutierrez - 4

di Resta - 5
Sutil - 5

Maldonado - 2
Bottas - 7

Ricciardo - 4
Vergne - 6

Pic - 3
van der Garde - 4

Bianchi - 6
Chilton - 5

Gerudo Dragon · Post by **Gerudo Dragon** » 25 Mar 2013, 05:05

Vettel - 0 Why are people rating this prick so highly?
Webber - 10

Alonso - 1
Massa - 7

Button - 9
Perez - 3

Raikkonen - 4
Grosjean - 7

Hamilton - 8
Rosberg - 8

Hulkenberg - 6
Guttierez - 4

Di Resta - 5
Sutil - 7

Maldonado - 1
Bottas - 4

Ricciardo - 3
Vergne - 7

Pic - 6
Van Der Garde - 5

Bianchi - 8
Chilton - 4

Teams:
Red Bull - 5
Ferrari - 4
McLaren - 4
Lotus - 6
Mercedes - 8
Sauber - 5
Force India - 0
Williams - 3
Toro Rosso - 4
Caterham - 3
Marussia - 6

Post by **Londoner** » 25 Mar 2013, 09:36

darkapprentice77 wrote:Vettel - 0 Why are people rating this prick so highly?

Because, like it or not, he did put in a fantastic performance. :roll:

Look, I don't like the guy, but I don't constantly give him zero. Zero should be for performances like Hamilton in Monaco in 2011, or Grosnado at Belgium last year, where it's almost inconcievable that they could have been any worse that afternoon.

Aerond · Post by **Aerond** » 25 Mar 2013, 12:27

Vettel - 10 -- Like it or not; excellent pace all weekend and that move on Webber was great.
Webber - 9 -- Perfect if not for losing the lead.

Alonso - 2 -- The extra 2 points for a good qualifying and staying a whole lap in 2nd, but that was never going to work.
Massa - 6 -- The average Massa came back during the race.

Button - 8 -- Overcame the problems of his car
Perez - 3 -- Where was he?

Raikkonen - 5 -- Shaved a few points, but it was a bit disappointing after Australia.
Grosjean - 6 -- Did a good job, but that's it.

Hamilton - 8 -- The more badass his driving is, the more I like him
Rosberg - 8 -- Showed progress and not ready to let Hamilton step over him.

Hulkenberg - 6 -- Respectable job
Guttierez - 4 -- Where was he?

Di Resta - 5 -- Average
Sutil - 5 -- Average

Maldonado - 3 -- Not looking good for Pastor
Bottas - 5 -- Did a respectable job in the end.

Ricciardo - 4 -- He's looking a bit anonymous, isn't he?
Vergne - 6 -- Good drive.

Pic - 5 -- He was Ok I guess
Van Der Garde - 4 -- Going to earn "most anonymous driver of the year" award

Bianchi - 8 -- Good showing again.
Chilton - 4 -- Looking ordinary.

tristan1117 · Post by **tristan1117** » 25 Mar 2013, 13:56

Vettel - 9
Webber - 9

Alonso - 1
Massa - 7

Button - 7
Perez - 4

Raikkonen - 3
Grosjean - 8

Hamilton - 8
Rosberg - 8

Hulkenberg - 9
Guttierez - 3

Di Resta - 5
Sutil - 5

Maldonado - 1
Bottas - 5

Ricciardo - 5
Vergne - 5

Pic - 5
Van Der Garde - 5

Bianchi - 8
Chilton - 3

takagi_for_the_win · Post by **takagi_for_the_win** » 25 Mar 2013, 15:26

Vettel- 8
Webber- 8

Alonso- 2
Massa- 7

Button- 8
Perez- 6

Raikkonen- 6
Grosjean- 8

Hamilton- 7
Rosberg- 8

Hulkenberg- 6
Guttierez- 4

Di Resta- 5
Sutil- 6

Maldonado- 2
Bottas- 7

Ricciardo- 5
Vergne- 6

Pic- 5
Van Der Garde- 4

Bianchi- 7
Chilton- 5

rachel1990 · Post by **rachel1990** » 25 Mar 2013, 16:34

Vettel - 7 Apart from not listening to his team he drove okay.
Webber - 10- Great race and should have won

Alonso - 1- Should have pitted and could have caused a big accident
Massa - 5 good at the end but just disappeared

Button - 8 Great drive but his team let him down big time
Perez - 5 First points for the team but he expected more from them

Raikkonen - 4 Not a great drive from the Iceman
Grosjean - 6 Good points keep the team second in the constructors

Hamilton - 7 Apart from driving into the wrong box he had another strong day
Rosberg - 7 Had more pace than Hamilton at the end

Hulkenberg - 8 the hulk kept Kimi at bay and showed some decent driving skill
Guttierez - 3 Once again I forgot he was in the race

Di Resta -2 Very Unlucky not to finish
Sutil - 2 Ditto

Maldonado - 1 two DNFs The team this time are blaming KERS. But his qualifying was awful as well
Bottas - 5 Almost got a point in a dud car

Ricciardo - 1 Another DNF. Yes I know it was wet but almost everyone else didn't do any damage
Vergne - 4 Good drivng to earn a point but the pitstops were awful

Pic - 2 Another not great race
Van Der Garde - 2 At least he kept Chilton behind him

Bianchi - 9 He could be in a red bull next season if this contiunes
Chilton - 2 Very poor. Not showing much potential

Teams:
Red Bull - 6 The team might just implode
Ferrari - 5 Should have ordered Alonso In
McLaren - 2 Pitstop nightmare cost Jenson bigtime
Lotus - 5 Not a great race
Mercedes - 8 Kept control over the drivers
Sauber - 7 Good strategy with The hulk
Force India - 1. The first double DNF of the season when they look quite strong
Williams - 3 the car is still really bad
Toro Rosso - 2 Too many teams had pitstop issues today
Caterham - 2 Can't get close to Bianchi
Marussia - 5 Bianchi could get them points

Driver ROTR- Alonso
Team ROTR -Force India

NAM · Post by **NAM** » 26 Mar 2013, 01:09

Vettel & Webber- 9 - Both did a great job and both deserved to win. Anyway I think we've already discussed this and I believe we can agree that both had a fine race.

Alonso - 2 - That wasn't going to work.
Massa - 6 - Qualified 2nd, finished 5th. Had a bad first lap and was average during the race.

Button - 9 - McLaren, just fix your problems please. It's a shame that drives like these end up with nothing.
Perez - 5 - Scored points, still destroyed by Button.

Räikkönen - 5 - A shadow of the driver he was in Australia.
Grosjean - 8 - Surprisingly good race for him. I hope he keeps this level.

Hamilton & Rosberg - 8 - Nice race, showed that there are no problems like the ones at Red Bull.

Hulkenberg - 8 - Good race.
Gutiérrez - 5 - Finishing races isn't really enough.

Di Resta - 6 - You can't do much when the team doesn't help.
Sutil - 6 - See Di Resta.

Maldonado - 1 - I bet if he only had $10 million in his wallet he would have been fired already.
Bottas - 6 - Not bad for a 2nd race.

Ricciardo - 5 - Still the driver with the most average drives.
Vergne - 6 - Well, he scored a point after crashing in the pits.

Pic - 5 - Doesn't really look like a non-rookie...
van der Garde - 6 - Kept the car running. We don't expect him to do much more than that.

Bianchi - 8 - I know you can get that point.
Chilton - 4 - Finished one lap behind van der Garde, so...

johnnyCarwash · Post by **johnnyCarwash** » 26 Mar 2013, 13:07

Vettel 8 - Would be 1 rating point higher if it wasn't for his end of the race antics
Webber 9 - Managed a good start for once. Benefited from Vettel being the guinea pig on slicks. Shame about the end.
Red Bull Racing 6 - This is for their image being severely tarnished at the end of the race. Also what tyre problems (saturday news)? They finished the race 1 - 2 for bathplug's sake (which saves their rating)

Alonso 2 - Rejectful race from Mr consistant. Surprised he didn't realise his wing wasn't attached properly.
Massa 7 - Forced into covering Vettel's early slick stop. Was pretty anonymous afterwards despite an excellent qualy lap.
Ferrari 6 - I expected this team to score the most points this weekend, and they didn't due to an uncharacteristic error with Alonso and a bad pit call ruined Massa's afternoon

Button 9 - What a performance! probably a 10 if he had finished
Pérez 7 - Average performance. Not helped by strategy. Does gain a point for fastest lap.
McLaren 5 - Another pit error guys. At least their understanding why they are so slow. Probably glad China is 3 weeks away.

Räikkönen 5 - From hero to zero. What a mediocre race from kimi. Doesn't look that comfortable in the wet. Being stuck behind cars didn't help, but going off at turn 12 twice was all his doing
Grosjean 9 - Outraced kimi for the first time in a while! Excellent performance. One of the few to have an uneventful race.
Lotus 7 - They were so strong in the dry. A good race but nothing special from these guys.

Rosberg 7 - Solid race
Hamilton 8 - Good qualy effort, and caused the Red Bulls problems before going into fuel save mode.
Mercedes 8 - Best ever result for Mercedes since they've entered in 2010. Sepang however is one of the team's stronger tracks. Shame about the amount of fuel.

Hülkenberg 8 - Impressive like Perez last year on the intermediate, still kept it solid in the race even giving Kimi something to think about
Gutiérrez 5 - Well beaten by his teammate
Sauber 6 - I was expecting this car to be beating Force India, and it isn't. First points of the season

Di Resta 6 - He looked hungry for once in the race being ahead of Sutil until the pit problem
Sutil 6 - Good qualy followed by a solid race until pit problem
Force India 1 - DNF on both cars says it all, wasted opportunity for good points from both drivers

Maldonado 3 - Beached it again...
Bottas 6 - Best of the new drivers however he did look silly having to change his nose before the race
Williams 6 - Not a bad race but nothing brilliant, average.

Vergne 8 - Got the point he deserved in Australia depite hitting a Caterham.
Ricciardo 6 - Average race. Shame he had to retire
STR 5 - Showing some promise except for the bathplug in the pits

Pic 7 - Outqualified Chilton.
Van der Garde 6 - Had a clean race
Caterham 6 - Still behind Marussia

Bianchi 8 - Awesome drive again
Chilton 6 - was outqualified by Pic. Bit of an eventful race for him which hampered his finishing potiiton.
Marussia 8 -With a couple of the midfield teams (notably Williams) faultering, maybe with another high attrition race they can score a point!

Dan B · Post by **Dan B** » 26 Mar 2013, 15:33

Vettel: 4: Sorry, but that is not how you win a race. Disobeying orders and acting like a prick just leaves a bad taste in my mouth, no matter of the drive.
Webber: 7: Should have won, but you never, ever shove someone else into the wall. I remember when this forum gave M. Schumacher a lot of flak for doing that to Barrichello. It's the same thing; you simply don't do that.
Red Bull: 3: Sort out your drivers and spend less time whining about tires.

Alonso: 1: What are you smoking?!
Massa: 7: Average.
Ferrari: 4: Swing and a miss.

Button: 8: Screwed over by his team.
Perez: 6: Not spectacular but he got points.
Mclaren: 3: just because the car sucks doesn't mean the rest of the team has to suck.

Hamilton: 7: Professional drive; handled team orders well.
Rosberg: 7: see above
Mercedes: 7: See Red Bull? This is how you handle your drivers.

Raikkonen: 5: The Sodman cometh, considering he did sod all during the race. At least he got some points.
Grosjean: 8: Had the measure of his teammate the entire weekend.
Lotus: 6: Where did the speed go?

Hulkenberg: 7: Showed pace but honestly I thought he was anonymous.
Gutierrez: 5: zzzzzzzz
Sauber: 4: Exciting as white bread currently.

Sutil: 5: See Button
di Resta: 5: See Sutil
Force India: 1: How does I puts on wheel?

Maldonado: 3: Well that was gormless.
Bottas: 4: Who?
Williams: 3: This isn't looking good.

Ricciardo: 4: nowhere
Vernge: 5: nowhere either but he did get a point.
Toro Rosso: 3: Remember when this team was in the upper midfield?

Pic: 5: Did okay I suppose
Van de Garde: 5: Okay he's more like Yamamoto than Ide now, but that is not saying much.
Caterham: 5: So much for the midfield but hey, they finished.

Bianchi: 9: Best driver of the weekend, by far.
Chilton: 5: Soundly beaten by Bianchi, yes, but he wasn't too bad.
Marussia: 6: Only team that did not screw up.

FMecha · Post by **FMecha** » 26 Mar 2013, 17:31

East Londoner wrote:
darkapprentice77 wrote:Vettel - 0 Why are people rating this prick so highly?

Because, like it or not, he did put in a fantastic performance.

Look, I don't like the guy, but I don't constantly give him zero. Zero should be for performances like Hamilton in Monaco in 2011, or Grosnado at Belgium last year, where it's almost inconcievable that they could have been any worse that afternoon.

That is what I call a blatant bias - I recall he had sig that he procalims to be a Vettel hater. Also, I think the rules says the rating span is one to ten - no zeroes allowed. :evil:

I did not saw the race so I cannot give a rating, proably until we raced in Europe.

Salamander · Post by **Salamander** » 26 Mar 2013, 18:44

FMecha wrote:
East Londoner wrote:
darkapprentice77 wrote:Vettel - 0 Why are people rating this prick so highly?

Because, like it or not, he did put in a fantastic performance.

Look, I don't like the guy, but I don't constantly give him zero. Zero should be for performances like Hamilton in Monaco in 2011, or Grosnado at Belgium last year, where it's almost inconcievable that they could have been any worse that afternoon.

That is what I call a blatant bias - I recall he had sig that he procalims to be a Vettel hater. Also, I think the rules says the rating span is one to ten - no zeroes allowed.

So? Everybody has bias.

dresda · Post by **dresda** » 26 Mar 2013, 23:11

Vettel

X61 · Post by **X61** » 28 Mar 2013, 22:19

Vettel - 9 - The only front runner who remembered that he was taking part in a motor race, not a Sunday drive to church.
Webber - 8 - Not bad for a number two driver.

Alonso - 1 - Stupidest thing I've seen in a while from someone of his ability.
Massa - 6 - Nothing special, but got a good result out of it.

Button - 8 - Great drive, ruined by McLaren.
Perez - 7 - New team, subpar car, not bad.

Raikkonen - 4 - Apparently thought he was in his WRC car.
Grosjean - 8 - Great drive, one of the few to keep it clean, which surprised me.

Hamilton - 7 - Good performance in that car. Another guy who apologized for no reason.
Rosberg - 4 - If you're really faster, shut up and drive.

Hulkenberg - 8 - For all the issues he claims the car has, very good drive. Admittedly assisted by the retirement of the FI cars.
Guttierez - 6 - Pretty good run, but victim of daft strategy. So basically a typical Sunday driving for Sauber.

Di Resta - 7 - Good drive, too bad he had issues with his nuts.
Sutil - 8 - Great drive, like he was never away. A victim of his team or their parts.

Maldonado - 1 - I lost track of how many times he went off while battling with the backmarkers.
Bottas - 5 - Hard to tell how good he is really doing until Maldonado screws his head on properly before a race.

Ricciardo - 3 - He was in Malaysia?
Vergne - 3 - He was in Malaysia?

Pic - 5 - Beat his teammate and Chilton, that's worth something.
van der Garde - 6 - Of all the people I would've suspected of crashing every other lap, he was one of the few who didn't.

Bianchi - 8 - Great qualifying and solid drive.
Chilton - 2 - Dead last of the cars running. A pity point for helping to finance a decent car for Bianchi.

QuickYoda41 · Post by **QuickYoda41** » 29 Mar 2013, 22:00

Drivers:
1. Mark Webber 8,65
2. Jenson Button 8,50
3. Jules Bianchi 7,88
4. Sebastian Vettel 7,77
5. Nico Rosberg 7,58
6. Nico Hülkenberg 7,54
7. Lewis Hamilton 7,50
8. Romain Grosjean 7,46
9. Felipe Massa 6,62
10. Valtteri Bottas 5,96
11. Jean-Eric Vergne 5,88
12. Paul Di Resta 5,80
13. Adrian Sutil 5,72
14. Sergio Perez 5,65
15. Giedo Van Der Garde 5,23
16. Charles Pic 5,08
17. Kimi Räikkönen 4,88
18. Daniel Ricciardo 4,58
19. Esteban Gutierrez 4,54
20. Max Chilton 3,92
21. Pastor Maldonado 2,23
22. Fernando Alonso 1,54

Teams:
1. Mercedes 8,14
2. Marussia 6,75
3. Red Bull 6,38
4. Lotus 6,25
5. Sauber 6,13
6. Ferrari 4,63
7. McLaren 4,25
8. Toro Rosso 4,00
9. Williams 4,00
10. Caterham 4,00
11. Force India 1,25

Grand Prix Rejects

F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia

Re: F1 Rejects Forum Ratings 2013 - R2 Malaysia