Complete List of ROTR's

The place for respectful and reverent discussion of Reject drivers and teams, whether profiled or not as yet
Alextrax52
Posts: 2943
Joined: 17 Apr 2013, 20:06
Location: Bromborough near Liverpool

Complete List of ROTR's

Post by Alextrax52 »

In case anyone has forgotten here are every single ROTR Jamie and Enoch that has been awarded

2000
FRA: Alex Wurz
AUT: Pedro Diniz
GER: Mercedes Employee
HUN: Marc Gene
BEL: Jenson Button
ITA: Heinz-Harald-Frentzen
USA: David Coulthard
JPN: Not Awarded
MAL: Not Awarded

2001
AUS: Awarded
MAL: Giancarlo Fisichella
BRA: Jos Verstappen
SMR: Benetton
ESP: Ferrari pit crew
AUT: Mika Hakkinen (and his start)
MON: Enrique Bernoldi
CAN: Juan Pablo Montoya
EUR: Ralf Schumacher
FRA: Heinz-Harald Frentzen
GBR: BAR
GER: Jarno Trulli
HUN: Jenson Button
BEL: Jamie and Enoch (For getting shown up by Fisichella)
ITA: Ferrari pit crew
USA: Jacques Villeneuve
JPN: Kimi Raikkonen

2002
AUS: Arrows
MAL: The Stewards
BRA: Pele
SMR: Jordan
ESP: Takuma Sato
AUT: Ferrari
MON: Felipe Massa
CAN: Williams
EUR: Giancarlo Fisichella
GBR: Michelin
FRA: Allan Mcnish's Engine
GER: Kimi Raikkonen
HUN: The Hungaroring
BEL: Honda
ITA: Felipe Massa
USA: Michael Scumacher/Rubens Barrichello
JPN: The Whole Field Bar Ferrari (Williams Mclaren Toyota Jaguar Jordan Renault BAR Minardi Sauber)

2003
AUS: Not Given
MAL: Michael Schumacher
BRA: Turn 3 (Curva do Sol)
SMR: Cristiano da Matta
ESP: Jacques Villeneuve
AUT: Toyota Launch Control
MON: Heinz-Harald Frentzen
CAN: The Team Bosses
EUR: David Coulthard
FRA: Renault
GBR: Neil Horan
GER: Bridgestone
HUN: Cosworth
ITA: Fernando Alonso
USA: Juan Pablo Montoya
JPN: Jacques Villeneuve

2004
AUS: 2004 new rules
MAL: Mark Webber
BHR: Ralf Schumacher
SMR: Juan Pablo Montoya
ESP: Ted Kravitz
MON: Michael Schumacher
EUR: Mercedes
CAN: Christian Klien
USA: Rubens Barrichello
FRA: TV Director
GBR: Olivier Panis
GER: Jarno Trulli/Flavio Briatore
HUN: Michelin
BEL: Mark Webber
ITA: The Trophies
CHN: Michael Schumacher
JPN: Typhoon Ma-on
BRA: Christian Klien

2005
AUS: Paul Stoddart
MAL: Honda
BHR: Ferrari
SMR: Mark Webber
ESP: Tonio Liuzzi
MON: Jacques Villeneuve
EUR: Kimi Raikkonen
CAN: Juan Pablo Montoya/Fernando Alonso
USA: Michelin
FRA: Williams
GBR: Mercedes
GER: Rubens Barrichello
HUN: Red Bull
TUR: Williams
ITA: Ferrari
BEL: Takuma Sato
BRA: Tiago Monterio's engine
JPN: Takuma Sato
CHN: Drain Covers

2006
BHR: Toyota
MAL: Williams
AUS: Honda
SMR: Yuji Ide
EUR: Nick Heifeld
ESP: Juan Pablo Montoya
MON: Michael Schumacher
GBR: Scott Speed
CAN: Nico Rosberg
USA: Takuma Sato
FRA: Honda
GER: Fernando Alonso
HUN: Michael Schumacher
TUR: Giancarlo Fisichella
ITA: The Stewards
CHN: Takuma Sato
JPN: Michael Schumacher's Engine
BRA: Williams

2007
AUS: David Coulthard
MAL: Felipe Massa
BHR: Nico Rosberg
ESP: BMW Pit-Crew
MON: Ralf Schumacher
CAN: Everyone except HAM HEI and WUR (ALO RAI WEB COU RSC TRU SAT MAS FIS KOV SPE LIU ALB SUT DAV BUT BAR ROS) KUB not involved
USA: The Stewards
FRA: Christijan Albers
GBR: Lewisteria
EUR: The tire gamblers (HAM KOV)
HUN: The stewards
TUR: Giancarlo Fisichella
ITA: Mike Gascoyne
BEL: Alex Wurz
JPN: Sebastian Vettel
CHN: Lewis Hamilton
BRA: ITV Commentary team (Knowing me i'd agree with J+E on this occasion)

2008
AUS: Kimi Raikkonen
MAL: Nico Rosberg
BHR: Fools Britannia Sextet (HAM ITV BUT COU NOTW MOS)
ESP: Adrian Sutil
TUR: Giancarlo Fisichella
MON: Kimi Raikkonen
CAN: Lewis Hamilton
FRA: Jenson Button
GBR: Felipe Massa
GER: Fernando Alonso
HUN: Refuelling Apparatus
EUR: The Valencia Track
BEL: The Stewards
ITA: Giancarlo Fisichella
SIN: Ferrari
JPN: Japan
CHN: Sebastien Bourdais
BRA: Felipe Massa's entourage

2009
AUS: Honda Fat Cat Executives
MAL: Bernie Ecclestone
CHN: Nelson Piquet JR
BHR: BMW Sauber
ESP: Ferrari
MON: Sebastian Vettel
TUR: Rubens Barrichello
GBR: Formula Elaborate Bluff
GER: Kimi Raikkonen
HUN: Bits Falling Off Cars
EUR: Luca Badoer
BEL: Kimi Raikkonen's KERS
ITA: Heikki Kovalainen
SIN: Adrian Sutil
JPN: Sebastien Buemi/Jaime Alguersuari
BRA: Jarno Trulli
ABU: Giancarlo Fisichella

2010
BHR: 2010 Season Overhyping
AUS: Mark Webber
MAL: Sauber
CHN: Tonio Liuzzi
ESP: Bruno Senna
MON: Article 40.13
TUR: Sebastian Vettel/Christian Horner/Helmut Marko
CAN: Michael Schumacher
EUR: Race Control
GBR: BMW Pit Crew
GER: Force India
HUN: Michael Schumacher
BEL: Sebastian Vettel
ITA: Nico Hulkenberg
SIN: Kamui Kobayashi
JPN: Lucas di Grassi
KOR: Adrian Sutil
BRA: Tonio Liuzzi
ABU: Abu Dhabi Rosewater

2011
AUS: Rubens Barrichello
MAL: Bits Flying off Toro Rosso's
CHN: Jenson Button
TUR: Michael Schumacher
ESP: Mark Webber's Strategy
MON: Lewis Hamilton
CAN: Stumbling Marshal
EUR: Hermann Tilke
GBR: Lotus
GER: Michael Schumacher/Sebastian Vettel
HUN: Jerome D'Ambrosio
BEL: Lewis Hamilton
ITA: Tonio Liuzzi
SIN: Renault
JPN: Kamui Kobayashi
KOR: Vitaly Petrov
IND: Felipe Massa
ABU: Pastor Maldonado
BRA: Virgin

2012
AUS: Pastor Maldonado
MAL: Romain Grosjean
CHN: Mercedes Doomsday Prophets
BHR: Daniel Ricciardo
ESP: Bruno Senna
MON: Pastor Maldonado
CAN: Jenson Button
EUR: Alternators
GBR: Nico Rosberg
GER: Podium Interviews
HUN: Michael Schumacher
BEL: Romain Grosjean/Pastor Maldonado
ITA: Red Bull
SIN: Narain Karthikeyan
JPN: Sergio Perez
KOR: F1 Gangnam Style (Korean GP Marshalls. Astroturf. Psy. Adrian Newey's Goggles. Badgering Korean GP Podium Girl.)
IND: The New Delhi Haze
ABU: Mark Webber
USA: Mercedes
BRA: Paul Di Resta

2013
AUS: Pastor Maldonado
MAL: World Chumpion Quartet (Red Bull. Ferrari. Lewis Hamilton. Kimi Raikkonen.)
CHN: Esteban Gutierrez
BHR: Jenson Button
ESP: Lewis Hamilton
MON: Romain Grosjean
CAN: Giedo Van der Garde
GBR: The Tyre Debate
GER: Jules Bianchi's Marussia
HUN: Force India
BEL: Sebastian Vettel's Blond Hair
ITA: Paul di Resta
SIN: The Stewards
KOR: The Fire Marshal's Jeep
JPN: Jules Bianchi/Giedo Van der Garde
IND: Kimi Raikkonen
ABU: Kimi Raikkonen
USA: Pastor Maldonado
BRA: Felipe Massa

2014
AUS: Red Bull
MAL: Andrew Murdoch
BHR: Pastor Maldonado
CHN: The Flag Man
ESP: Mclaren
MON: Adrian Sutil/Esteban Gutierrez
CAN: Max Chilton
AUT: Red Bull GmbH
GBR: Esteban Gutierrez
GER: Race Control
HUN: Romain Grosjean
BEL: Lewis Hamilton/Nico Rosberg
ITA: Ferrari
SIN: Unspecified Foreign Substance
JPN: Not Awarded
RUS: Not Awarded
USA: Not Awarded
BRA: Not Awarded
ABU: Not Awarded

2015
AUS: Sergio Perez
MAL: Marcus Ericsson
CHN: Chinese GP Marshals
BHR: Renault
ESP: McLaren
MON: Lynch Mob Mentality
CAN: Romain Grosjean
AUT: Kimi Raikkonen
GBR: Sauber
HUN: Lewis Hamilton/Nico Rosberg
BEL: Williams
ITA: The FIA
SIN: Track Invader/The Organisers
JPN: Not Awarded
RUS: Crazy Russian Marshal
USA: Not Awarded
MEX: Not Awarded
BRA: Renault
ABU: Williams

2016
AUS: The New Qualifying System
BAH: Force India
CHN: Jolyon Palmer
RUS: Daniil Kvyat
ESP: Mercedes
Last edited by Alextrax52 on 27 Aug 2014, 13:23, edited 19 times in total.
User avatar
Jocke1
Posts: 2604
Joined: 31 Dec 2010, 00:13

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by Jocke1 »

That's a lot of Rejects. :lol:
Great list.
-*:-
User avatar
Londoner
Posts: 6423
Joined: 17 Jun 2010, 18:21
Location: Norwich, UK
Contact:

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by Londoner »

I still maintain awarding Bernoldi ROTR for Monaco 2001 is absolutely outrageous. If he'd done that 10 or so years later to Hamilton or someone, we'd be lauding him for his fighting spirit and defensive prowess. :evil:
Fetzie on Ferrari wrote:How does a driver hurtling around a race track while they're sous-viding in their overalls have a better understanding of the race than a team of strategy engineers in an air-conditioned room?l
User avatar
UncreativeUsername37
Posts: 3420
Joined: 25 May 2012, 14:36
Location: Earth

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by UncreativeUsername37 »

East Londoner wrote:I still maintain awarding Bernoldi ROTR for Monaco 2001 is absolutely outrageous. If he'd done that 10 or so years later to Hamilton or someone, we'd be lauding him for his fighting spirit and defensive prowess. :evil:

If anything, it should be Monaco.
Rob Dylan wrote:Mercedes paying homage to the other W12 chassis by breaking down 30 minutes in
User avatar
pi314159
Posts: 3660
Joined: 11 Aug 2012, 12:12

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by pi314159 »

East Londoner wrote:I still maintain awarding Bernoldi ROTR for Monaco 2001 is absolutely outrageous. If he'd done that 10 or so years later to Hamilton or someone, we'd be lauding him for his fighting spirit and defensive prowess. :evil:

I agree. The worst ROTR decision I think. They could have given ROTR either to the circuit, Montoya (for that stupid crash at the habour chicane), or Burti, who was 2.5 seconds slower than Alesi in qualifying and spent the whole race in second last position.
pasta_maldonado wrote:The stewards have recommended that Alan Jones learns to drive.
User avatar
go_Rubens
Posts: 3415
Joined: 25 Mar 2013, 21:12
Location: A raging river somewhere in the Eastern (cough) United States (cough)

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by go_Rubens »

pi314159 wrote:
East Londoner wrote:I still maintain awarding Bernoldi ROTR for Monaco 2001 is absolutely outrageous. If he'd done that 10 or so years later to Hamilton or someone, we'd be lauding him for his fighting spirit and defensive prowess. :evil:

I agree. The worst ROTR decision I think. They could have given ROTR either to the circuit, Montoya (for that stupid crash at the habour chicane), or Burti, who was 2.5 seconds slower than Alesi in qualifying and spent the whole race in second last position.


Yeah, I find the Bernoldi one a bit harsh.
Felipe Baby, Stay Cool

Albert Einstein wrote:Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the universe.
Alextrax52
Posts: 2943
Joined: 17 Apr 2013, 20:06
Location: Bromborough near Liverpool

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by Alextrax52 »

Of the 4 races where J+E didn't give the award to anyone Japan 2000 should have gone to Prost for another shocker of a weekend and another Peugeot Motor detonated. Malaysia 2000 would probably go to Pedro Diniz for causing the opening lap pile up and then for trying to 3-wheel his car back to the pits. If not him then Jordan for a poor afternoon which saw Trulli come 12th and last and Frenzten retiring. Australia 2001 should go to Gaston Mazzacane who qualified 20th only faster than Burti and Marques and not even getting around the first lap. Australia 2003 should go to Mark Webber's car for robbing him of a potential victory.

Of the first 8 races of 2000 i would have gone for the following
AUS: British teams (Mclaren Jaguar Jordan Arrows Williams for qualifying)
BRA: Sauber (For the rear wing fiasco)
SMR: Jos Verstappen (Drove like a tool all weekend)
GBR: Arrows (Identical problems with both cars and they were the first 2 cars out)
ESP: Arrows (again) (17 cars finished and Arrows were the only team not to get a car to the finish)
EUR: Jaguar (Both cars caught up in accidents)
MON: Jean Alesi's transmission (Robbed him of a potential podium place)
CAN: Jacques Villeneuve (For his moment of sheer brain fade)
User avatar
James1978
Posts: 3033
Joined: 26 Jul 2010, 18:46
Location: Darlington, NE England

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by James1978 »

These are my favourite RotR's of each year (i.e. the funniest)

2000: Wurz (France)
2001: Fisichella (Malaysia)
2002: Massa (Monaco)
2003: Team Bosses (Canada)
2004: Webber (Malaysia)
2005: Montoya & Alonso (Canada)
2006: Ide (San Marino)
2007: The almost everyone in Canada
2008: Hamilton (Canada)
2009: Bernie Ecclestone (Malaysia)
2010: Sauber pit crew (Great Britian)
2011: Stumbling marshall (canada - that race seems to feature a lot for comedy gaffes!)
2012: F1 Gangnam Style (Korea)
2013 so far: World Chumpion Quartet (Malaysia)
"Poor old Warwick takes it from behind all throughout this season". :) (Tony Jardine, 1988)
Alextrax52
Posts: 2943
Joined: 17 Apr 2013, 20:06
Location: Bromborough near Liverpool

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by Alextrax52 »

James1978 wrote:These are my favourite RotR's of each year (i.e. the funniest)

2000: Wurz (France)
2001: Fisichella (Malaysia)
2002: Massa (Monaco)
2003: Team Bosses (Canada)
2004: Webber (Malaysia)
2005: Montoya & Alonso (Canada)
2006: Ide (San Marino)
2007: The almost everyone in Canada
2008: Hamilton (Canada)
2009: Bernie Ecclestone (Malaysia)
2010: Sauber pit crew (Great Britian)
2011: Stumbling marshall (canada - that race seems to feature a lot for comedy gaffes!)
2012: F1 Gangnam Style (Korea)
2013 so far: World Chumpion Quartet (Malaysia)


Interesting choices James1978 however the funniest for 2002 for me was Japan when they gave it to the whole field except Ferrari.
User avatar
go_Rubens
Posts: 3415
Joined: 25 Mar 2013, 21:12
Location: A raging river somewhere in the Eastern (cough) United States (cough)

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by go_Rubens »

Kimi-ICE wrote:
James1978 wrote:These are my favourite RotR's of each year (i.e. the funniest)

2000: Wurz (France)
2001: Fisichella (Malaysia)
2002: Massa (Monaco)
2003: Team Bosses (Canada)
2004: Webber (Malaysia)
2005: Montoya & Alonso (Canada)
2006: Ide (San Marino)
2007: The almost everyone in Canada
2008: Hamilton (Canada)
2009: Bernie Ecclestone (Malaysia)
2010: Sauber pit crew (Great Britian)
2011: Stumbling marshall (canada - that race seems to feature a lot for comedy gaffes!)
2012: F1 Gangnam Style (Korea)
2013 so far: World Chumpion Quartet (Malaysia)


Interesting choices James1978 however the funniest for 2002 for me was Japan when they gave it to the whole field except Ferrari.


I don't understand the "Everyone bar Ferrari" because when would Minardi be faster than Ferrari?
Felipe Baby, Stay Cool

Albert Einstein wrote:Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the universe.
User avatar
James1978
Posts: 3033
Joined: 26 Jul 2010, 18:46
Location: Darlington, NE England

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by James1978 »

I think the Japan 2002 award should have been split two ways between Williams and McLaren - based on expectations, you wouldn't seriously expect any of the other teams to have regularly challenged Ferrari (with perhaps the exception of Renault but they were rebuilding having taken over from Benetton who had a miserable 2001). Slightly arguably Jordan and BAR too but definitely nobody else.

Whereas Massa's Monaco race that year was just so bad it was laughable. :)
"Poor old Warwick takes it from behind all throughout this season". :) (Tony Jardine, 1988)
User avatar
takagi_for_the_win
Posts: 3054
Joined: 02 Oct 2011, 01:38
Location: The land of the little people.

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by takagi_for_the_win »

James1978 wrote:I think the Japan 2002 award should have been split two ways between Williams and McLaren - based on expectations, you wouldn't seriously expect any of the other teams to have regularly challenged Ferrari (with perhaps the exception of Renault but they were rebuilding having taken over from Benetton who had a miserable 2001). Slightly arguably Jordan and BAR too but definitely nobody else.

Yeah, I found it harsh to. I mean, at the start of 2002, people were talking of a 3-way battle between McLaren, Ferrari and Williams for the title, so they deserved a stake of the ROTR. However, to give the award to Minardi, and to a lesser extent Toyota, always struck me as being a bit harsh
TORA! TORA! TORA!
User avatar
DOSBoot
Posts: 1638
Joined: 26 Dec 2010, 19:09
Location: Pensacola, Florida. United States.

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by DOSBoot »

Now THAT"S the list I have been waiting for! Great job there!
Proud supporter of the United States 2nd Amendment.

2012 Predicament Predictions Champion.
Alextrax52
Posts: 2943
Joined: 17 Apr 2013, 20:06
Location: Bromborough near Liverpool

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by Alextrax52 »

DOSBoot wrote:Now THAT"S the list I have been waiting for! Great job there!


I'd been waiting to do this long before i registered for this website. Now everyone knows who's won them all

Of the current grid this is how they won them

Vettel
Japan 2007: Imagine if that was Webber's only shot at a victory
Monaco 2009: Wasted a golden chance for victory and eventually binned it at St Devote
Turkey 2010 (Shared with Horner and Marko): For his part in the Red Bull fiasco
Belgium 2010: For those amateur crashes with Button and Liuzzi
Germany 2011 (Shared with Michael Schumacher): Underwhelming weekend

Webber
Malaysia 2004: Saturday's hero to Sunday's absolute zero
Belgium 2004: For triggering the first lap pile-up
San Marino 2005: Went backwards in the race
Canada 2007: Along with 17 other drivers he screwed up at some point
Australia 2010: Amateurish race by his standards
Abu Dhabi 2012: 3 stupid collisions

Alonso
Italy 2003: Hungary hero to Italy zero
Canada 2005 (Shared with Juan Pablo Montoya): Moment of hot-headedness
Germany 2006: Off the pace all race
Canada 2007: Along with 17 other drivers he screwed up at some point
Germany 2008: Woeful race probably sealed because of Piquet's podium

Massa
Monaco 2002: Master of disaster all weekend
Italy 2002: Collision with Pedro De La Rosa
Malaysia 2007: Reckless overtake on Hamilton
Canada 2007: Along with 17 other drivers he blew it at some point
Great Britain 2008: Made his 2002 race look good with 5 spins
India 2011: Clunked the same kerb not once but twice

Button
Belgium 2000: Too hasty and took out Trulli
Hungary 2001: Another dismal weekend
Canada 2007: See above]
Bahrain 2008: For his part in fools britannia sextet
France 2008: Only man to not finish in the race
China 2011: Stopped in the wrong box and got beat by a guy that started 18th
Canada 2012: Canada 2011 hero to Canada 2012 absolute zero
Bahrain 2013: Clumsy attempts to assert his authority

Perez
Japan 2012: Drove like a clown and was destroyed by Kobayashi

Raikkonen
Japan 2001: Denied Jean Alesi a perfect finishing record
Germany 2002: France hero to Germany zero
Europe 2005: Error strewn 2nd half of the race culminated in the flatspot
Canada 2007: See above
Australia 2008: Pathetic start to a title defence
Monaco 2008: Took out Sutil denying a (provisional) dream result for Force India
Germany 2009: Took out Sutil denying a (Permanent) dream result for Force India
Malaysia 2013 (Shared with Red Bull Ferrari and Lewis Hamilton): His part was for a WRC style race

Grosjean
Malaysia 2012: Only lasted 4 laps
Belgium 2012 (Shared with Pastor Maldonado): For causing the first lap carnage

Rosberg
Canada 2006: Inexperience led to his retirement
Bahrain 2007: Struggled all weekend
Canada 2007: See above
Malaysia 2008: Hero to Zero in just one race
Britain 2012: Any more anonymous he'd be a Hacktivist (What is a Hacktivist)

Hamilton
Europe 2007 (Shared with Heikki Kovalainen): For a dreadful tire call
China 2007: Rookie decision to stay out cost him dearly
Bahrain 2008: See Button
Canada 2008: Forgot how traffic-lights work
Monaco 2011: Poor Race and a Childish interview
Belgium 2011: Poor Driving against Kobayashi
Malaysia 2013 (Shared with Red Bull Ferrari and Kimi Raikkonen): Stopped at the wrong box
Spain 2013: Fell from 2nd to a lapped 12th

Hulkenberg
Italy 2010: For his chicane cutting antics

Gutierrez
China 2013: Forgot to brake

Di Resta
Brazil 2012: Crushed by The Hulk and crashed on his own

Sutil
Canada 2007: See above
Spain 2008: Took out Vettel in an opening corner crash
Singapore 2009: Ended Nick Heidfeld's Finishing run through no fault of his own
Korea 2010: Spent all race passing Sauber's before crashing into Kobayashi

Maldonado
Abu Dhabi 2011: Ignored Blue Flags
Australia 2012: Costly crashes gave him this one
Monaco 2012: Spain Hero to Monaco's absolute Zero
Belgium 2012 (Shared with Romain Grosjean): Helped with the opening lap pile up
Australia 2013: Overdrove his underperforming Williams

Ricciardo
Bahrain 2012: Fell from 6th to 17th on the first lap with no apparent problem

Vernge Bottas Pic Chilton Van der Garde and Bianchi have yet to win the award

I'll have to leave the other ROTR's for another time
Faustus
Site Donor
Site Donor
Posts: 2073
Joined: 30 Mar 2009, 20:23
Location: UK

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by Faustus »

Kimi-ICE wrote:In case anyone has forgotten here are every single ROTR Jamie and Enoch have awarded


This is great. Thanks for compiling it. Can you please keep updating it?
Following Formula 1 since 1984.
Avid collector of Formula 1 season guides and reviews.
Collector of reject merchandise and 1/43rd scale reject model cars.
Alextrax52
Posts: 2943
Joined: 17 Apr 2013, 20:06
Location: Bromborough near Liverpool

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by Alextrax52 »

Faustus wrote:
Kimi-ICE wrote:In case anyone has forgotten here are every single ROTR Jamie and Enoch have awarded


This is great. Thanks for compiling it. Can you please keep updating it?


Mate I'll keep updating it in the same manner that tc3j3r keeps updating the ROTR leaderboard
User avatar
good_Ralf
Posts: 2681
Joined: 06 Jun 2013, 13:14
Location: Hitchin, UK

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by good_Ralf »

I'm on a roll! I'm going to start the list of ROTR-winners that are currently not in action and other winners, plus the races that they could also be nominated for. The order will be decided by who got it first.

Mr. Wurz, it's your turn. :lol:

Wurz

France 2000: And what was Wurz doing? Now that's being in fairyland
Belgium 2007: Another lackluster performance while Rosberg shines again
Also worth noting: Canada 1998, Europe 2000, Japan 2007

Diniz

Austria 2000: Dangerous and anonymous race really summed up his season
Also worth noting: Argentina 1996, Germany 2000, Malaysia 2000

Men on track

Germany 2000: Probable protest against getting sacked by Mercedes ultimately leads to a Mercedes-powered team losing the race!
Britain 2003: What someone on YouTube said: A future BGT contestant auditions in front of the cars in the Hanger Straight
Canada 2011: Fell in front of F1 cars not once, but twice!
Also worth noting: Spain 2004

Gene

Hungary 2000: Austria Hero to Hungary Zero

Frentzen

Italy 2000: Braked too late, knocking out Trulli, Barrichello, Coulthard etc. and (indirectly) sadly father-to-be marshal Paolo Ghislimberti (hope I spelt that right :? )
France 2001: Was nowhere again as speculation about his Jordan seat increases
Monaco 2003: Crashed on the first lap despite his experience
Also worth noting: Monaco 1996, Brazil 1997, Monaco 1997, Spain 1997, Britain 1997, Japan 1998, Monaco 2000, Monaco 2001, Hungary 2003

Coulthard

USA 2000: Jump-started, with disastrous consequences for McLaren
Japan 2002: Didn't get close to Ferrari (broken throttle)
Europe 2003: Got out-smarted by brake-troubled Alonso, then blamed the Spaniard for his spin-off
Hungary 2005: Was just in the wrong place at the wrong time
Australia 2007: Almost amputated Wurz's hands with his unbelievably bad attempt to overtake
Canada 2007: Blew it at some point (set-up)
Bahrain 2008: Fool's Britannia (collided with Button)
Also worth noting: Hungary 1994, Canada 1995, Australia 1995, Argentina 1998, Belgium 1998, Brazil 1999

I've done Fisichella for fun, of course

Verstappen

Brazil 2001: Ended the Colombian dream for another 6 months
Also worth noting: Pacific 1994, Monaco 1996, Germany 1996, Australia 1997, San Marino 2000, Europe 2000, Brazil 2003

Benetton

San Marino 2001: Got beaten by Wonderkid Alonso in qualifying
Also worth noting: San Marino 1998

Häkkinen

Austria 2001: Another stall on the grid is not the stuff of championships
Also worth noting: Portugal 1993, Monaco 1994, Germany 1994, Canada 1995, Belgium 1995, San Marino 1999, Italy 1999

Bernoldi

Monaco 2001: Holding up a much faster car for a few laps is fine, but for half the race is truly frustrating

Montoya

Canada 2001: Crashed out again
Japan 2002: Didn't get close to Ferrari (nowhere near the frontrunners)
USA 2003: Comedy of errors put him out of the title battle
San Marino 2004: Couldn't stop thinking of how to retaliate against M Schumacher
Canada 2005: Drove through a red-light at pit-exit
Spain 2006: Spun it away on a heavy fuel load
Also worth noting: Monaco 2001, Hungary 2001, Brazil 2002, Hungary 2002, Australia 2003, Europe 2004, Australia 2006, Canada 2006, USA 2006 etc.

R Schumacher

Europe 2001: Frustration about his brother's move caused his own mistake
Japan 2002: Didn't get close to Ferrari (blew up)
Bahrain 2004: Cartoonish collision with Sato before an unnecessary stop
Monaco 2007: Gets a silly salary for running dead last at the start
Canada 2007: Blew it at some point (got strategy wrong)
Also worth noting: Argentina 1997, Belgium 1997, Italy 1997, Luxembourg 1997, Brazil 1998, Canada 1998, Japan 2000, USA 2001, Canada 2006 etc.

BAR

Britain 2001: Teammate collision at the start
Japan 2002: Didn't get close to Ferrari (both cars broke down)
Also worth noting: All of 1999 ;) ,Most of 2002, The first half of 2005

Trulli

Germany 2001: Spun and then suffered hydraulics failure
Japan 2002: Didn't get close to Ferrari (broke down)
Germany 2004: Got into a row with Flav after a bad day
Canada 2007: Blew it at some point (crashed coming out of pit-lane)
Brazil 2009: Spectacular outburst with Sutil, but it was his own fault!
Also worth noting: Australia 2002, Germany 2002, Spain 2003, Britain 2003, Hungary 2003, The final 3 races of 2005, Australia 2006, France 2007 etc.

Villeneuve

USA 2001: Was abysmal in quali and got infected by 1999 Hill-tivitus
Japan 2002: Didn't get close to Ferrari (blew-up spectacularly)
Spain 2003: Was hungry not to lose to JB in the media as well
Japan 2003: Had a hissy-fit over not being re-signed by BAR
Monaco 2005: Kamikaze turned Sauber's 5 points into 0 instantly
Also worth noting: Monaco 1996, Canada 1997, Germany 1997, Germany 1998, Italy 1998, San Marino 1999, Canada 2000, Malaysia 2005

Arrows

Australia 2002: Both cars get disqualified for silly things
Also worth noting: Hungary 1997, Spain 2000 etc.

The Stewards

Malaysia 2002: Montoya didn't deserve the first-ever DTP
Italy 2006: Biased towards Ferrari?
USA 2007: Even if it was the case, a 10-place grid penalty for an alleged illegal overtake is ridiculous
Hungary 2007: McLaren and Alonso didn't deserve those harsh penalties
Belgium 2008: Lewis' actions were academic when Räikkönen spun...

Pele

Brazil 2002: When has anyone forgotten to wave the chequered flag?!

Jordan

San Marino 2002: Qualified in mid-field and then both cars retired with the same problem
Japan 2002: Didn't get close to Ferrari (semi-quick but unreliable)
Also worth noting: Belgium 1991, All of 1992

Sato

Spain 2002: Spectacular spin into the gravel
Japan 2002: Didn't get close to Ferrari (first points though...)
Belgium 2005: Stupidly rammed Schumacher
Japan 2005: Apalling race performance at home
USA 2006: Cost Super Aguri their first points
China 2006: Big-headed baulking cost Heidfeld big points
Canada 2007: Blew it at some point (poor tyre strategy)
Also worth noting: Monaco 2002, France 2002, France 2005, China 2005, Canada 2006

Michelin

Britain 2002: No real intermediate tyres? You must be joking!
Hungary 2004: Had no answer to Bridgestone's pace with Ferrari
USA 2005: Caused Indygate. Nuff said.

Allan McNish's engine

France 2002: Responsible for losing Kimi his first win and giving Schumi the title just one race early

Honda

Belgium 2002: Engines were only good at blowing up :shock:
Malaysia 2005: Even an exploitation of the rules couldn't save BAR from a double-DNF
Australia 2006: Button goes from pole straight down to 5th and then blows-up on the finish line!
France 2006: Were off the pace and both cars suffered engine failure

Kimi-ICE has already listed Schumacher's ROTRs

Barrichello

USA 2002: Tried to dead-heat with Schumi but ended up winning instead
USA 2004: Took pole but couldn't beat his unstoppable teammate and later found more excuses
Germany 2005: Could barely escape the clutches of the Minardis
Canada 2007: Blew it some point (team's strategy)
Turkey 2009: His poor start began a slide down the field before a DNF
Australia 2011: Had three separate incidents at the same corner
Also worth noting: Brazil 1996, Monaco 1996, Brazil 2001, Australia 2003, Japan 2004

Curva do Sol

Brazil 2003: Standing water put out 6 cars and cost Minardi a win (?)

Da Matta

San Marino 2003: Awful baulking when being lapped

Team Bosses

Canada 2003: More action off-track than on-track
Australia 2005: Paul Stoddart declares he's using his old cars

Renault

Japan 2002: Didn't get close to Ferrari (couldn't match pace or reliability)
France 2003: Double-DNF at home GP
Singapore 2011: Anonymous compared to early races
Also worth noting: Canada 2004, Hungary 2005, Brazil 2007, All of 2009, Japan 2010

Bridgestone

Germany 2003: Were off the pace of the Michelins
Also worth noting: All of 2005

Cosworth

Hungary 2003: Suffered five failures in the same event

2004 new rules

Australia 2004: Attempts to spice up the sport probably only made things worse

(Ted) Kravitz

Spain 2004: Would report on anything, even a track protester (Jimmy Jump!)

Mercedes

Europe 2004: Motors comparable to WMDs
Britain 2005: Two straight races with a faiLure for Räikkönen
USA 2012: Were simply going nowhere
Also worth noting: Australia 2011

Klien

Canada 2004: Tried his best not to score for Jaguar
Brazil 2004: Caused teammate collision in Jaguar's finale
Also worth noting: All of 2006 bar Bahrain and Germany

TV director

France 2004: Spent the whole race focussing on Schumacher and Alonso
Also worth noting: Japan every year

Panis

Japan 2002: Didn't get close to Ferrari (throttle failed)
Britain 2004: Blocked Massa in qualifying and got his just-desserts with a fire-extinguisher explosion
Also worth noting: France 1995, Italy 2004

The Trophies

Italy 2004: An ugly cigarette shape
Also worth noting: Bahrain 2004

Typhoon Ma-on

Japan 2004: Failed to lash chaos on Suzuka a la 1994

Liuzzi

Spain 2005: Terrible underperformance in the Red Bull
Canada 2007: Blew it at some point (hit the Wall of Champions)
China 2010: Caused first-lap pile-up
Brazil 2010: Crashed out trying to save his future
Italy 2011: Got HRT momentarily into the points by losing control and causing a(nother) pile-up
Also worth noting: Turkey 2006, Germany 2010

Monteiro's engine

Brazil 2005: Spoilt the rookie's perfect finishing record

Drain Covers

China 2005: Should have been fastened down but took out Montoya instead

Toyota

Japan 2002: Didn't get close to Ferrari (a bad home race with McNish crashing)
Austria 2003: Launch control caused two aborted starts :oops:
Bahrain 2006: Were anonymous even with their massive resourses
Also worth noting: Belgium 2005, Japan 2005, China 2006, Bahrain 2009

Ide

San Marino 2006: Flipped Albers off attempting not to be dead last

Heidfeld

Japan 2002: Didn't get close to Ferrari (ran in the mid-field)
Europe 2006: Nowhere near Villeneuve all weekend
Also worth noting: Austria 2002

Speed

Britain 2006: Overambitious move put himself out and two other cars
Canada 2007: Blew it at some point (clashed with Wurz)

Michael Schumacher's Engine

Japan 2006: Fails when Schumi on on the cusp of beating Alonso
Also worth noting: France 1996, France 2000

BMW (Sauber) Pit-Crew

Spain 2007: Premature release leads to yet more nonsense
Britain 2010: The rear wing isn't important, eh?

Albers

Canada 2007: Blew it at some point (crashed out)
France 2007: Simply left the pits without warning
Also worth noting: Australia 2007

Lewisteria

Britain 2007: Overhyped Hamilton too much

Kovalainen

Canada 2007: Blew it at some point (crashed in practice and quali)
Europe 2007: Poor tyre and fuel strategy cost him first podium
Italy 2009: Nodded off with a heavy fuel load instead of using it to win the race
Also worth noting: Belgium 2008, Monaco 2009, Belgium 2012

(Mike) Gascoyne

Italy 2007: Overhyped Spyker's new car

ITV

Brazil 2007: Was biased towards Hamilton
Bahrain 2008: Wrongly accused Alonso of causing a collision

Refuelling Apparatus

Hungary 2008: Caused multiple pit fires
Also worth noting: Germany 2001

Valencia's Circuit

Europe 2008: An exciting layout flattered to decieve
Also worth noting: Every year bar 2012

Japan

Japan 2008: The Hondas and Nakajima were last plus no Super Aguri

Bourdais

China 2008: Collided with Trulli in a very boring race
Also worth noting: All of 2009

Massa's entourage

Brazil 2008: Celebrated after Hamilton crossed the line

Honda Fat Cat Executives

Australia 2009: Unperformed and quit just before their successors overperformed!

(Bernie) Ecclestone

Malaysia 2009: In order to get more viewers, Sepang got caught in a monsoon

Piquet Jr.

China 2009: Needed to change front wing twice
Also worth noting: Singapore 2008, Australia 2009

BMW (Sauber)

Bahrain 2009: Their cars came last
Malaysia 2010: Both cars retire due to engine problems
Also worth noting: Germany 2006, all of 2009 bar Belgium and Brazil

Formula Elaborate Bluff

Britain 2009: No wonder Mosley called them idiots

Bits falling off cars

Hungary 2009: Injured Massa and temporarily banned Renault
Malaysia 2011: Toro Rosso debris caused Pérez's retirement

Badoer

Europe 2009: Look-how-bad-you-are
Also worth noting: His gearbox in Europe 1999

KERS

Belgium 2009: Beat Force India to their maiden win

Buemi/Alguersuari

Japan 2009: Crashed multiple times

2010 Season Overhyping

Bahrain 2010: New rules produced a mildly boring race

Senna

Spain 2010: Got outqualified by Chandok and crashed on the first lap
Spain 2012: Awful weekend compared to his winning teammate...
Also worth noting: Belgium 2011, Brazil 2012

Article 40.13

Monaco 2010: Arbitrary rule penalized an opportunistic Schumacher

Race Control

Europe 2010: Same as Monaco - Gave out unnecessary penalties

Force India

Germany 2010: Both cars got eliminated in Q1 and languished at the tail of the field
Also worth noting: Britain 2008, Singapore 2009, Canada 2011

Kobayashi

Singapore 2010: Crashed and blocked the track
Japan 2011: Poor home race with stupid tyre strategy
Also worth noting: Canada 2010, China 2012, Europe 2012, Korea 2012

di Grassi

Japan 2010: Crashed heavily at 130R - on the installation lap :lol:
Also worth noting: All of 2010

Rosewater

Abu Dhabi 2010: Pathetic substitute for champagne

Webber's strategy

Spain 2011: Put Mark out of contention for the win
Also worth noting: Spain 2005

(Hermann) Tilke

Europe 2011: Boring race thanks to his design

Lotus

Britain 2011: Both cars out in the early laps on home soil

D'Ambrosio

Hungary 2011: Spun into his pit-box

Petrov

Korea 2011: Ran into Schumacher
Also worth noting: Australia 2010, Korea 2010, Malaysia 2011

Virgin

Brazil 2011: Final race saw the cars qualify dead last before Glock lost a wheel

Alternators

Europe 2012: Put Vettel and Grosjean out of winning positions

Podium Interviews

Germany 2012: Sucked
Also worth noting: Every race :mrgreen:

Karthikeyan

Singapore 2012: The first driver to crash in the race
Also worth noting: China 2005

Indian Smog

India 2012: Added tone to the worst race of year
Last edited by good_Ralf on 15 Jun 2013, 16:35, edited 7 times in total.
Check out the position of the sun on 2 August at 20:08 in my garden

Allard Kalff in 1994 wrote:OH!! Schumacher in the wall! Right in front of us, Michael Schumacher is in the wall! He's hit the pitwall, he c... Ah, it's Jos Verstappen.
User avatar
go_Rubens
Posts: 3415
Joined: 25 Mar 2013, 21:12
Location: A raging river somewhere in the Eastern (cough) United States (cough)

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by go_Rubens »

Good list, mate! I'm glad you'll continue the list!
Felipe Baby, Stay Cool

Albert Einstein wrote:Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the universe.
User avatar
James1978
Posts: 3033
Joined: 26 Jul 2010, 18:46
Location: Darlington, NE England

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by James1978 »

Fantastic list!

How about Spa 1998 for Coulthard though? The first-start accident, collding with Wurz at the restart, lifting off for Schumi instead of moving over. Plus being sent out again when it was a hopeless cause.
"Poor old Warwick takes it from behind all throughout this season". :) (Tony Jardine, 1988)
User avatar
dr-baker
Posts: 15428
Joined: 29 Mar 2009, 17:30
Location: Here and there.

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by dr-baker »

A thought went through my head post-Canadian GP, and this thread has helped. After the death of the marshall at the Canadian GP, I was wondering whether it would be appropriate or not for something like ROTR to be awarded. I used to read F1 News magazine in the 1990s, and their tagline was always, "Puts The Fun Into Formula One." But in their post-Imola 1994 issue, they dropped this tagline (which normally went immediately under their title on the cover), and dropped their "Caption This" feature, etc. Looking at the list above, it appears that ROTR was awarded after the death of Paolo Ghislimberti at the 2000 Italian GP, but not after the death of Graham Beveridge at the 2001 Australian GP. Was this because of the death of the marshall, or some other reason? Should this be awarded if there has been something tragic taking place?

Image
watka wrote:I find it amusing that whilst you're one of the more openly Christian guys here, you are still first and foremost associated with an eye for the ladies!
dinizintheoven wrote:GOOD CHRISTIANS do not go to jail. EVERYONE ON FORMULA ONE REJECTS should be in jail.
MCard LOLA
User avatar
wsrgo
Posts: 651
Joined: 03 Apr 2013, 11:18
Location: India

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by wsrgo »

Amazing how Fisichella made it a point to clinch ROTR three years in a row at Istanbul.

And then he went and overtook Lewis Hamilton for position at Istanbul in 2009, driving a Force India. I know the McLaren was crap, but still....
eytl wrote:I agree. Especially when he talks about one's nerves sending signals 111a and 6783 etc. to the brain upon seeing Ericsson's hairdo.

He's got it all wrong. When I see Ericsson and Chilton's hairdos, the only signal going to my brain is 1049.
User avatar
go_Rubens
Posts: 3415
Joined: 25 Mar 2013, 21:12
Location: A raging river somewhere in the Eastern (cough) United States (cough)

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by go_Rubens »

I think the funniest ROTR so far this year has been Bianchi's Phantom Marussia.
Felipe Baby, Stay Cool

Albert Einstein wrote:Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the universe.
User avatar
rachel1990
Posts: 948
Joined: 29 Oct 2012, 20:21

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by rachel1990 »

I'm Going to give my ROTY opinions (From 2000 onwards)
2000 - Prost. 0 points dodgy car and drivers hitting each other. Defo ROTY
2001- DC's Title bid- It wasn't. He won 2 races at the start of the year and then disappeared.
2002- Alex Yoong - I have to agree with J+E here. Needed more testing time
2003- Jacques Villeneuve- never came to grip with having competition at the team and left. BAR were better without him
2004 - (Joint Award) Williams and Mclaren - were meant to challenge Ferrari and didn't get close
2005 - Rubens Barrichello - Didn't really try in his last season for the prancing horse
2006 - Cosworth - Bad way to go out of f1 with so many engine failures
2007- Alonso vs Hamilton- the feud between them cost Mclaren both titles in the end
2008- Jenson Button- J+E were right here. the only time I saw him was the ITV opening titles
2009- Nelson Piquet JR- Horrible driver on and off the track. I hope I never see him anywhere near a f1 car again
2010- Michael Schumacher- So much hype. Nothing delivered
2011- Williams - I never thought they would sink lower than this (I was wrong)
2012- Maldonado and Senna (Joint Award) Wasted a very good Williams

2013 top 3 so far (Its all teams at the moment)
1. Mclaren (How the mighty have fallen)
2. Williams (See above)
3. Sauber ( no money and seemingly no talent in one of the cars (not the Hulk)
Benetton of 1992. Never a reject
Alextrax52
Posts: 2943
Joined: 17 Apr 2013, 20:06
Location: Bromborough near Liverpool

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by Alextrax52 »

rachel1990 wrote:I'm Going to give my ROTY opinions (From 2000 onwards)
2000 - Prost. 0 points dodgy car and drivers hitting each other. Defo ROTY
2001- DC's Title bid- It wasn't. He won 2 races at the start of the year and then disappeared.
2002- Alex Yoong - I have to agree with J+E here. Needed more testing time
2003- Jacques Villeneuve- never came to grip with having competition at the team and left. BAR were better without him
2004 - (Joint Award) Williams and Mclaren - were meant to challenge Ferrari and didn't get close
2005 - Rubens Barrichello - Didn't really try in his last season for the prancing horse
2006 - Cosworth - Bad way to go out of f1 with so many engine failures
2007- Alonso vs Hamilton- the feud between them cost Mclaren both titles in the end
2008- Jenson Button- J+E were right here. the only time I saw him was the ITV opening titles
2009- Nelson Piquet JR- Horrible driver on and off the track. I hope I never see him anywhere near a f1 car again
2010- Michael Schumacher- So much hype. Nothing delivered
2011- Williams - I never thought they would sink lower than this (I was wrong)
2012- Maldonado and Senna (Joint Award) Wasted a very good Williams

2013 top 3 so far (Its all teams at the moment)
1. Mclaren (How the mighty have fallen)
2. Williams (See above)
3. Sauber ( no money and seemingly no talent in one of the cars (not the Hulk)


2001: Now that you mention it DC's title challenge wasn't great. He outraced Michael fairly and squarly twice all season and never after his Austrian victory. Also maybe Hakkinen's poor year made him look better than he was that year

2003: Villeneuve's comments about Button certainly didn't help him. Battling the Minardi's for 18th at the Nurburging summed up his year perfectly

2004: While Williams and Mclaren were poor and Pantano is obvious i would give a mention to the Trulli/Briatore fall out. In the December 2004 edition of F1 Racing it said that even at Monaco where Trulli won that Flavio praised the team instead of Jarno and of course France was the last straw.

For 2007 Lewisteria should get it because the hype around Lewis was immense and unruly. Also it really was Villeneuve 1996 all over again in which Jacques drove the best car on the grid to many wins and fought for the title and look what happened to him. Lewis wasn't tested in many situations where nothing works for him and people were still going on about Lewis can be one of the greatest drivers ever and i couldn't help having a big smile when Lewis lost the title and Raikkonen and the FIA burst the evil bubble. The hype today is still bad. Whenever A German Wins it's all about the car and when a Brit wins it's because he's amazing.

2012 could have seen anyone take the award but i gave it to Mclaren. If you want to know why check the start of page 3 in the Reject of the year for years that were not covered thread
User avatar
takagi_for_the_win
Posts: 3054
Joined: 02 Oct 2011, 01:38
Location: The land of the little people.

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by takagi_for_the_win »

Freeze-O-Kimi wrote:For 2007 Lewisteria should get it because the hype around Lewis was immense and unruly. Also it really was Villeneuve 1996 all over again in which Jacques drove the best car on the grid to many wins and fought for the title and look what happened to him. Lewis wasn't tested in many situations where nothing works for him and people were still going on about Lewis can be one of the greatest drivers ever and i couldn't help having a big smile when Lewis lost the title and Raikkonen and the FIA burst the evil bubble. The hype today is still bad. Whenever A German Wins it's all about the car and when a Brit wins it's because he's amazing.

I think the hype around a rookie coming into the pinnacle of motorsport and matching and beating the reigning two-time champion (and heir apparent to Schumi) in equal machinery was possibly justified. Never mind the fact that back then, he was a thoroughly likable chappie and there you have the reasons for everyone liking him.
TORA! TORA! TORA!
User avatar
Londoner
Posts: 6423
Joined: 17 Jun 2010, 18:21
Location: Norwich, UK
Contact:

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by Londoner »

Controversial choice, but I think Jordan deserve a mention for the 2001 ROTY, for the way they treated Frentzen and the shambles that followed his sacking, which pretty much set the team on the course it followed until Eddie Jordan sold up in 2004. But I guess that's with hindsight applied.

2005, in my (highly biased) opinion, should go to the no tyre changing rule, for being an incredibly stupid and dangerous rule, and at least partially causing the Indy 2005 fiasco. Plus the fact that it rendered many of the races dull as ditchwater. But enough of my ranting on this.

2008 should have gone to the stewarding we saw that year, for being godawful. Bourdais's penalty at Fuji absolutely takes the biscuit. :evil:

To be honest, I'd give the 2012 ROTY to either Senna or Mercedes. Like it or not, Bruno was nowhere near The Reverend all year, he was so slow. I gave him the benefit of the doubt in 2010 because he was driving such a dreadful car, and in 2011 because he was parachuted in with miminal testing into a car that was steadily sliding down the field as the season progressed, but he had to impress in 2012, and he had a great chance to do so. Which he didn't take advantage of, unless being stuck behind a Caterham for half the race at MONTREAL of all places is a qualifying factor of some sort, because that is impressive, if for the wrong reasons...:P
Fetzie on Ferrari wrote:How does a driver hurtling around a race track while they're sous-viding in their overalls have a better understanding of the race than a team of strategy engineers in an air-conditioned room?l
Alextrax52
Posts: 2943
Joined: 17 Apr 2013, 20:06
Location: Bromborough near Liverpool

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by Alextrax52 »

East Londoner wrote:Controversial choice, but I think Jordan deserve a mention for the 2001 ROTY, for the way they treated Frentzen and the shambles that followed his sacking, which pretty much set the team on the course it followed until Eddie Jordan sold up in 2004. But I guess that's with hindsight applied.

2005, in my (highly biased) opinion, should go to the no tyre changing rule, for being an incredibly stupid and dangerous rule, and at least partially causing the Indy 2005 fiasco. Plus the fact that it rendered many of the races dull as ditchwater. But enough of my ranting on this.

2008 should have gone to the stewarding we saw that year, for being godawful. Bourdais's penalty at Fuji absolutely takes the biscuit. :evil:

To be honest, I'd give the 2012 ROTY to either Senna or Mercedes. Like it or not, Bruno was nowhere near The Reverend all year, he was so slow. I gave him the benefit of the doubt in 2010 because he was driving such a dreadful car, and in 2011 because he was parachuted in with miminal testing into a car that was steadily sliding down the field as the season progressed, but he had to impress in 2012, and he had a great chance to do so. Which he didn't take advantage of, unless being stuck behind a Caterham for half the race at MONTREAL of all places is a qualifying factor of some sort, because that is impressive, if for the wrong reasons...:P


I don't think nominating Jordan for 2001 ROTY is controversial at all mate. From what I've read on Wikipedia because the Jordan's were very quick in pre-season testing and many thought that Jordan would be the team to take on Ferrari and Mclaren for title honors. As we know Jordan scored no podiums and only just finished ahead of BAR and were beaten by Sauber on a smaller budget. Sure bad luck played it's part with Frentzen losing 3rd in Brazil thanks to Gearbox Failure and Trulli suffered 5 retirements in a row at the end of the season. The car they had was great in Qualifying with many top 6's on the grid but they couldn't keep it going in the races. San Marino was the only time both cars scored points and after that race Frentzen would not score again for the rest of the year which ultimately led to his sacking from the team.

I suppose the only thing you like about 2005 was that Ferrari's domination ended? Part of it was down to Bridgestone suffering to produce a compound that could be fast and durable at the same time with the notable exception being Imola. However Ross Brawn himself admitted that the F2005 wasn't the greatest Ferrari the team had ever built. I think that's down to the fact that there had been no change for some time at Ferrari and they didn't have any new ideas.

As for the 2008 stewarding you only need to look at the Belgian GP ROTR to understand how good stewarding was in 2008 :lol:
User avatar
good_Ralf
Posts: 2681
Joined: 06 Jun 2013, 13:14
Location: Hitchin, UK

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by good_Ralf »

Freeze-O-Kimi wrote:I don't think nominating Jordan for 2001 ROTY is controversial at all mate. From what I've read on Wikipedia because the Jordan's were very quick in pre-season testing and many thought that Jordan would be the team to take on Ferrari and Mclaren for title honors. As we know Jordan scored no podiums and only just finished ahead of BAR and were beaten by Sauber on a smaller budget. Sure bad luck played it's part with Frentzen losing 3rd in Brazil thanks to Gearbox Failure and Trulli suffered 5 retirements in a row at the end of the season. The car they had was great in Qualifying with many top 6's on the grid but they couldn't keep it going in the races. San Marino was the only time both cars scored points and after that race Frentzen would not score again for the rest of the year which ultimately led to his sacking from the team.


I'd put Jordan in middle of my 2001 rankings, if not lower, but if there was one year where they would take ROTY outright, it would be 1992. They had a gutless car with poor pace, terrible reliability and a godawful paint job compared to the 1991 car. With some good but problematic drivers, they only scored 1 point all season and were 11th in the standings, which today is Caterham/Marussia territory!
Check out the position of the sun on 2 August at 20:08 in my garden

Allard Kalff in 1994 wrote:OH!! Schumacher in the wall! Right in front of us, Michael Schumacher is in the wall! He's hit the pitwall, he c... Ah, it's Jos Verstappen.
User avatar
wsrgo
Posts: 651
Joined: 03 Apr 2013, 11:18
Location: India

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by wsrgo »

good_Ralf wrote:[I'd put Jordan in middle of my 2001 rankings, if not lower, but if there was one year where they would take ROTY outright, it would be 1992. They had a gutless car with poor pace, terrible reliability and a godawful paint job compared to the 1991 car. With some good but problematic drivers, they only scored 1 point all season and were 11th in the standings, which today is Caterham/Marussia territory!


Wasn't that the year they had Yamaha works engines? I don't remember much about Jordan that season, except that their former driver, driving a Benetton, crashed into Stefano Modena (Magny-Cours, was it :?: )...after having allegedly been given the 'evil eye' by Ayrton Senna..

We know who that is.. :P
eytl wrote:I agree. Especially when he talks about one's nerves sending signals 111a and 6783 etc. to the brain upon seeing Ericsson's hairdo.

He's got it all wrong. When I see Ericsson and Chilton's hairdos, the only signal going to my brain is 1049.
User avatar
good_Ralf
Posts: 2681
Joined: 06 Jun 2013, 13:14
Location: Hitchin, UK

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by good_Ralf »

wsrgo wrote:Wasn't that the year they had Yamaha works engines?


Yes it was. :) I think they contributed to Jordan's downfall, given how they had a wonderful debut season in 1991. At least Yamaha helped Arrows nearly win a race!
Check out the position of the sun on 2 August at 20:08 in my garden

Allard Kalff in 1994 wrote:OH!! Schumacher in the wall! Right in front of us, Michael Schumacher is in the wall! He's hit the pitwall, he c... Ah, it's Jos Verstappen.
User avatar
Onxy Wrecked
Posts: 1762
Joined: 11 Dec 2012, 03:23
Location: Dodging Potholes and Snowshowers

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by Onxy Wrecked »

Freeze-O-Kimi wrote:
DOSBoot wrote:Now THAT"S the list I have been waiting for! Great job there!


I'd been waiting to do this long before i registered for this website. Now everyone knows who's won them all

Of the current grid this is how they won them

Vettel
Japan 2007: Imagine if that was Webber's only shot at a victory
Monaco 2009: Wasted a golden chance for victory and eventually binned it at St Devote
Turkey 2010 (Shared with Horner and Marko): For his part in the Red Bull fiasco
Belgium 2010: For those amateur crashes with Button and Liuzzi
Germany 2011 (Shared with Michael Schumacher): Underwhelming weekend

Webber
Malaysia 2004: Saturday's hero to Sunday's absolute zero
Belgium 2004: For triggering the first lap pile-up
San Marino 2005: Went backwards in the race
Canada 2007: Along with 17 other drivers he screwed up at some point
Australia 2010: Amateurish race by his standards
Abu Dhabi 2012: 3 stupid collisions

Alonso
Italy 2003: Hungary hero to Italy zero
Canada 2005 (Shared with Juan Pablo Montoya): Moment of hot-headedness
Germany 2006: Off the pace all race
Canada 2007: Along with 17 other drivers he screwed up at some point
Germany 2008: Woeful race probably sealed because of Piquet's podium

Massa
Monaco 2002: Master of disaster all weekend
Italy 2002: Collision with Pedro De La Rosa
Malaysia 2007: Reckless overtake on Hamilton
Canada 2007: Along with 17 other drivers he blew it at some point
Great Britain 2008: Made his 2002 race look good with 5 spins
India 2011: Clunked the same kerb not once but twice

Button
Belgium 2000: Too hasty and took out Trulli
Hungary 2001: Another dismal weekend
Canada 2007: See above]
Bahrain 2008: For his part in fools britannia sextet
France 2008: Only man to not finish in the race
China 2011: Stopped in the wrong box and got beat by a guy that started 18th
Canada 2012: Canada 2011 hero to Canada 2012 absolute zero
Bahrain 2013: Clumsy attempts to assert his authority

Perez
Japan 2012: Drove like a clown and was destroyed by Kobayashi

Raikkonen
Japan 2001: Denied Jean Alesi a perfect finishing record
Germany 2002: France hero to Germany zero
Europe 2005: Error strewn 2nd half of the race culminated in the flatspot
Canada 2007: See above
Australia 2008: Pathetic start to a title defence
Monaco 2008: Took out Sutil denying a (provisional) dream result for Force India
Germany 2009: Took out Sutil denying a (Permanent) dream result for Force India
Malaysia 2013 (Shared with Red Bull Ferrari and Lewis Hamilton): His part was for a WRC style race

Grosjean
Malaysia 2012: Only lasted 4 laps
Belgium 2012 (Shared with Pastor Maldonado): For causing the first lap carnage

Rosberg
Canada 2006: Inexperience led to his retirement
Bahrain 2007: Struggled all weekend
Canada 2007: See above
Malaysia 2008: Hero to Zero in just one race
Britain 2012: Any more anonymous he'd be a Hacktivist (What is a Hacktivist)

Hamilton
Europe 2007 (Shared with Heikki Kovalainen): For a dreadful tire call
China 2007: Rookie decision to stay out cost him dearly
Bahrain 2008: See Button
Canada 2008: Forgot how traffic-lights work
Monaco 2011: Poor Race and a Childish interview
Belgium 2011: Poor Driving against Kobayashi
Malaysia 2013 (Shared with Red Bull Ferrari and Kimi Raikkonen): Stopped at the wrong box
Spain 2013: Fell from 2nd to a lapped 12th

Hulkenberg
Italy 2010: For his chicane cutting antics

Gutierrez
China 2013: Forgot to brake

Di Resta
Brazil 2012: Crushed by The Hulk and crashed on his own

Sutil
Canada 2007: See above
Spain 2008: Took out Vettel in an opening corner crash
Singapore 2009: Ended Nick Heidfeld's Finishing run through no fault of his own
Korea 2010: Spent all race passing Sauber's before crashing into Kobayashi

Maldonado
Abu Dhabi 2011: Ignored Blue Flags
Australia 2012: Costly crashes gave him this one
Monaco 2012: Spain Hero to Monaco's absolute Zero
Belgium 2012 (Shared with Romain Grosjean): Helped with the opening lap pile up
Australia 2013: Overdrove his underperforming Williams

Ricciardo
Bahrain 2012: Fell from 6th to 17th on the first lap with no apparent problem

Vernge Bottas Pic Chilton Van der Garde and Bianchi have yet to win the award

I'll have to leave the other ROTR's for another time

Bianchi's car did the reject act instead although Bianchi was out of the car and it was the track marshals who let it roll back onto the track like a phantom menace.
More Moneytron, more problems for Onyx!
A flock of Kroghs appear on the NASCAR Track and cause caw-tions!
User avatar
wsrgo
Posts: 651
Joined: 03 Apr 2013, 11:18
Location: India

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by wsrgo »

I think Ralf Schumacher deserved the ROTR for the 2001 Japanese Grand Prix than Kimi Raikkonen.
eytl wrote:I agree. Especially when he talks about one's nerves sending signals 111a and 6783 etc. to the brain upon seeing Ericsson's hairdo.

He's got it all wrong. When I see Ericsson and Chilton's hairdos, the only signal going to my brain is 1049.
Alextrax52
Posts: 2943
Joined: 17 Apr 2013, 20:06
Location: Bromborough near Liverpool

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by Alextrax52 »

wsrgo wrote:I think Ralf Schumacher deserved the ROTR for the 2001 Japanese Grand Prix than Kimi Raikkonen.


I think he also deserves Japan 2003 ROTR. That had to be one of the most pathetic drives of his career i've ever seen. He didn't set a time in qualifying because it was wet when he ran then he had a mindless spin early in the race before he almost took out his own brother fighting for the championship and coming home a lapped 12th
User avatar
FullMetalJack
Site Donor
Site Donor
Posts: 6269
Joined: 31 Mar 2009, 15:32
Location: Some place far away. Yes, that'll do.

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by FullMetalJack »

Freeze-O-Kimi wrote:
wsrgo wrote:I think Ralf Schumacher deserved the ROTR for the 2001 Japanese Grand Prix than Kimi Raikkonen.


I think he also deserves Japan 2003 ROTR. That had to be one of the most pathetic drives of his career i've ever seen. He didn't set a time in qualifying because it was wet when he ran then he had a mindless spin early in the race before he almost took out his own brother fighting for the championship and coming home a lapped 12th


I definitely agree on 2003.
I like the way Snrub thinks!
Alextrax52
Posts: 2943
Joined: 17 Apr 2013, 20:06
Location: Bromborough near Liverpool

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by Alextrax52 »

While we are on the topic of ROTY I would like to nominate Sergio Perez for 2012. The 3 podium places were great (even if he used strategy for them) but it's worth remembering he scored 51 of his 66 points for the season in those 3 races. Had we had a normal year he would have only scored 1 point more than in 2011 where he missed 2 races so he would have scored less than the Maligned Bruno Senna and would have been ROTY
User avatar
dinizintheoven
Posts: 3982
Joined: 09 Dec 2010, 01:24

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by dinizintheoven »

And I'll nominate Nigel Mansell for 1992's Reject Of The Year. The wins were great (even if he used the Williams FW14B to get them), but if we ignore those, he'd have finished equal on points with Jean Alesi in the execrable Ferrari F92A, and if we discount all his podiums he'd have scored no points at all, just like Perry McCarthy! In an Andrea Moda!

If fact, let's count up the points for that year using the current system, and see who would have outscored Nige if we forget about his podiums. Olivier Grouillard! Paul Belmondo! Eric van de Poele! In fact, even Gabriele Tarquini would have finished ahead of him via getting the Fondmetal to the finish line once, and if that doesn't scream "Reject Of The Year", I don't know what does!

Sergio Pérez was unavailable for comment.
James Allen, on his favourite F1 engine of all time:
"...the Life W12, I can't describe the noise to you, but imagine filling your dustbin with nuts and bolts, and then throwing it down the stairs, it was something akin to that!"
User avatar
watka
Site Donor
Site Donor
Posts: 4097
Joined: 26 Apr 2009, 19:04
Location: Chessington, the former home of Brabham
Contact:

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by watka »

dinizintheoven wrote:And I'll nominate Nigel Mansell for 1992's Reject Of The Year. The wins were great (even if he used the Williams FW14B to get them), but if we ignore those, he'd have finished equal on points with Jean Alesi in the execrable Ferrari F92A, and if we discount all his podiums he'd have scored no points at all, just like Perry McCarthy! In an Andrea Moda!

If fact, let's count up the points for that year using the current system, and see who would have outscored Nige if we forget about his podiums. Olivier Grouillard! Paul Belmondo! Eric van de Poele! In fact, even Gabriele Tarquini would have finished ahead of him via getting the Fondmetal to the finish line once, and if that doesn't scream "Reject Of The Year", I don't know what does!

Sergio Pérez was unavailable for comment.


I hope Freeze-O-Kimi finds your sarcasm as funny as I do, for your sake. :lol:
Watka - you know, the swimming horses guy
User avatar
go_Rubens
Posts: 3415
Joined: 25 Mar 2013, 21:12
Location: A raging river somewhere in the Eastern (cough) United States (cough)

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by go_Rubens »

watka wrote:I hope Freeze-O-Kimi finds your sarcasm as funny as I do, for your sake. :lol:


How he is able to say something funny on the internet is perplexing to me. I find a lot of what he writes funny, especially his post in the 2013 Predictions Thread :lol:
Felipe Baby, Stay Cool

Albert Einstein wrote:Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the universe.
User avatar
FullMetalJack
Site Donor
Site Donor
Posts: 6269
Joined: 31 Mar 2009, 15:32
Location: Some place far away. Yes, that'll do.

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by FullMetalJack »

watka wrote:
dinizintheoven wrote:And I'll nominate Nigel Mansell for 1992's Reject Of The Year. The wins were great (even if he used the Williams FW14B to get them), but if we ignore those, he'd have finished equal on points with Jean Alesi in the execrable Ferrari F92A, and if we discount all his podiums he'd have scored no points at all, just like Perry McCarthy! In an Andrea Moda!

If fact, let's count up the points for that year using the current system, and see who would have outscored Nige if we forget about his podiums. Olivier Grouillard! Paul Belmondo! Eric van de Poele! In fact, even Gabriele Tarquini would have finished ahead of him via getting the Fondmetal to the finish line once, and if that doesn't scream "Reject Of The Year", I don't know what does!

Sergio Pérez was unavailable for comment.


I hope Freeze-O-Kimi finds your sarcasm as funny as I do, for your sake. :lol:


Maybe he needs a sarcasm sign.

Image
I like the way Snrub thinks!
User avatar
dinizintheoven
Posts: 3982
Joined: 09 Dec 2010, 01:24

Re: Complete List of ROTR's

Post by dinizintheoven »

I made one for exactly this purpose for a forum I used to frequent...

Image

...but I really didn't think it would be necessary. And yes, the banner is supposed to be painful to look at.
James Allen, on his favourite F1 engine of all time:
"...the Life W12, I can't describe the noise to you, but imagine filling your dustbin with nuts and bolts, and then throwing it down the stairs, it was something akin to that!"
Post Reply